Silent Hill Movie vs. Game Comparison
Top Comments
All Comments (205)
-
@RustCrimson - I had no idea what the hell you were talking about, till I realized my comment was from over 4yrs ago...
-
@xDilutedx We're not whining because there's a woman in it, because Heather was a great character that people love. We're whining about the fact that he stated the reason he was changed was based on some sexist standard that a father can't be sensitive and care for his daughter.
-
@kinnikuchu There was a reason. A stupid one, but there was one. He was based on a woman's sexuality, hence why he's buff and half naked.
-
@manicmuffin Thank you. About time someone saw it through my eyes.
-
@LovelyRoxxy Comparing with the Resident Evil movies, Alone in the Dark, Bloodrayne, Street Fighter, Super Mario Bros, Mortal Kombat Annihilation, and others... -.-
Yeah, it's a lot better...
-
In reality the plot would have been much better if the lead character switched over to him for the second hour... It should have played out like that chilling european flick "The Vanishing".
-
Anderson ironically did that for Mortal Kombat.... He loved that game and make a killer flick out of it before others fucked it up with the sequel.
but he did fuck up Resident Evil(even though he probably did love that game too).
-
Except if he was in Mortal Kombat directing mode.... in which case it would turn out to be one of the funnest video game adaptations ever and it would be near 100% faithful to the plot.
Remember he did make one absolute kick ass VG film....
I still love that Scorpion VS Johnny Cage fight scene! Still one of the most kickass fight scenes ever!
-
and this is EXACTLY why this is the greatest movie/video game adaptation. because the fucking director actually played the fucking game. not tried to make a quick buck by reading the cliffnotes


Personally, I felt the movie did justice to Silent Hill. I know it wasn't perfectly accuarate in some things, but still it was pretty good compared to other game/movie adaptations...
LovelyRoxxy 1 year ago 7
the director clearly gave a shit about S.H, if this was in the hands of the resident evil director, the mom would be doing backflips and shooting monsters in slow motion.
favianutube 5 months ago 5