Pink Floyd - Have a Cigar (Solo)

Pink Floyd's Have a Cigar solo by David Gilmour. Performed by me.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Pink
• Floyd
• Have
• Cigar
• Wish
• you
• were
• here
• david
• gilmour
• roger
• waters

[taggs5858]

dude absolutely fuckin sick! dude abviously ur a huge pink floyd fan

------pink floyd, best band of all time

[craigrose007]

@hardhead621 24 years...

[Septimius]

@Antiks72 If you're referring to my own playing, I think it speaks for itself on your understanding of guitar playing if you think that idiom is fitting for my critique.

[Antiks72]

@Septimius Those who live in glass houses...

[Antiks72]

Those full bend vibratos are hard to do. Nice work.

[eftaxiaskostas]

Not even a little mistake...

You are great player!

[bajambalumbax]

great job dude, i love your feeling while you play and you did an awesome solo. just one thing: you've certainly noticed, while listening to pink floyd, that they tend to 'slow down' the beat, everything. don't know if you get what i'm saying, but i wanted to let you notice that you look like you're in a hurry during this solo.

[Septimius]

@casualtySR I am fairly certain I never said anyone was perfect. At any rate, discussions like these are futile, because you'll mold whatever I'm saying to fit your counter-arguments, and I can't help but take solace in the fact that I get why this is bad and you don't.

[casualtySR]

@Septimius I just listened to your attempt at Shine on you Crazy Diamond and honestly you made several mistakes going by your standards... bend errors, some of the improv didn't gel that well etc.. really sour note at 3:17, flub at 6:50 and some other spots. overall a good job like this guy tho. No one is perfect.

[Septimius]

@casualtySR I'm fairly certain you haven't checked my channel, in that case. At any rate, there's a difference between having an individual play style and just plain awful mistakes.Outside of the fact that all the interesting nuances from the original solo are lost, sections like the one at :25-0:28(probably being the worst offender) and 0:33, and how out of time 0:42-0:45 is, lack of bends at 0:55, the rest is a straight copy.You can't copy something and say "well, that's just me" when you miss

[casualtySR]

@Septimius The cool thing about guitars is that no guitarist sounds exactly alike, you should probably embrace that notion, especially if you play one... from a general stand point he plays the solo pretty damn close to the real thing. We can nitpick about every little bend or slight differences in tonality but that would be stupid.

[mhm143]

craigrose007 - I appreciate this video in helping visualize the solo. I thought it was well done. Great job.