Bach - Musikalisches Opfer BWV 1079 (1/6)
Uploader Comments (BachHarmony)
Top Comments
-
I feel like conducting a little informal poll: Thumbs up if when you listen to the Musical Offering, you almost feel as if you are hearing the very laws of the universe, aurally codified.
(Didn't Goethe say something like this?)
-
One thing bothers me. There are so many views for Part I, but only a fraction of listeners moved on to Part II and the numbers continue to decline after that. It's sad. People don't know what they're missing.
All Comments (33)
-
@LunaWHDavies7 I find the theme to be quite... horrible. What Bach had done to it is miraculous, but I find the "bare" thema regis at the very start anything but extraordinary. This is just my personal opinion, mind you!
-
@Paul1239193 What are you on about?
-
@Paul1239193 Yeah...but I thought Frederick II's interests as a youth were philosophy and music. He was a trained musician who tried to escape his father and his responsibilities, albeit he still ascended to the throne. But I get what you mean, the theme is quite extraordinary a composition in itself and was probably concocted by someone with a very solid musical background, and not someone like Frederick II.
-
This makes sense now: it was C. P. E. Bach who gave Frederick II the theme for A Musical Offering! It never made any sense to me that a politician, Frederick II, could motivate this sort of thing.
-
belissimo
-
@BachHarmony I've found it! It's the Concentus Musicus Wien.
amazon.com/Bach-J-S-Musical-Of
fering-Musikalisches/dp/B00002 4TA5 (or released with the Bach 2000 collection: amazon.com/Musical-Offering-Ba
ch/dp/B00004S4MX) I am delighted beyond belief. It's at an unbelievably low price.
Can anyone confirm what recording this is?
Is it Le concert des nations with Pierre Hantai on the harpsichord?
Gustaveleloup 2 months ago
@Gustaveleloup I don't remember it now... but all my recordings are taken from Bach 2000 set
BachHarmony 2 months ago