I disagree with the comments below. Lataji sings parts well but overall her rendering totally lacks emotions and transformation into a different mood based on the words and tune of this song. Even technically, Lata's rendition is not perfect to my ears. For example, in the first line she does not smoothly transform the notes from the word "samay" to "O"...she gives a gap there that breaks the smooth flow of the song. She does the same thing on different occasions throughout the song. (contd)
@sakibali786 additionally If one listens to this song only, one may conclude that Lata's voice has more gravity and feel to it..I think Asha's best work was her ghazals in Umrao Jan..but there also Lata seems to surpass in Pakeezah
I disagree with the comments below. Lataji sings parts well but overall her rendering totally lacks emotions and transformation into a different mood based on the words and tune of this song. Even technically, Lata's rendition is not perfect to my ears. For example, in the first line she does not smoothly transform the notes from the word "samay" to "O"...she gives a gap there that breaks the smooth flow of the song. She does the same thing on different occasions throughout the song. (contd)
kruven 2 weeks ago
@sakibali786 additionally If one listens to this song only, one may conclude that Lata's voice has more gravity and feel to it..I think Asha's best work was her ghazals in Umrao Jan..but there also Lata seems to surpass in Pakeezah
sheesabidi 4 weeks ago
@sakibali786 i know about you for a fact. But most of the similar videos are biased with Asha Bhosle..that's why I said
sheesabidi 4 weeks ago
lata rules,,,nyways
the sublime voice s needed fr this song..nt chirpy one
shiverhot 1 month ago
Wah wah wah the great Lata ji. Asha sings nice but Lata Ji makes the song. Very beautiful! Nice upload. bye Raj
MrRajkoemar 1 month ago
This is sublime music.
VispisAngel 1 month ago
lovely very nice thanks
KHAN1561 1 month ago