Peter Paul and Mary, A Soalin
Uploader Comments (cschoon1213)
Top Comments
-
This is the original to Sting's "Soul Cake". Paul Stookey wrote it together with Tracey Batteast & Elena Mezetti, based on the English folk song Hey ho, nobody home. First released on Peter, Paul and Mary's second album, Moving (1963).
All Comments (20)
-
What year was this
-
Ooh...I didn't know a version of this existed on YouTube! I have the Japanese album it's from. It's wonderful.
-
That last line of the intro "...the candy or your front window"still cracks me up even after all these years
P.s. I think one of their bass players was Milt Okun.
-
@kyanite2 More then likely the bass player was Dick Kniss who was with PP&M for their entire career. Paul Prestopino would often play backup guitar or mandolin as well
-
I was able to produce 1 .ffftve with the G-minor experiment. Any other tones?
Franklin Ghost Tones.
-
I love the guitar work at the beginning.
-
If you pay attention to the lyric, they were telling about the social unjust, Peter, Paul & Mary songs never dated. Just look around, what they have been telling still happens.
-
Oh my goodness! I sang this is in like, fourth grade or something in music class!!!! But only part of it.



I grew up with this! lol! sweet memories...thanks for sharing
rainbowcougar 1 year ago 2
@ rainbowcougar,
The pleasure is mine! :-)
cschoon1213 1 year ago
Wow! I don't know how many times Paul said his little preamble, but it sure sounds like the recording of this song. This must be from the sixties. They should give credit to the bass player who also played, I do believe, on Lightfoot's first album. Thanks so much for this posting!
kyanite2 2 years ago
My pleasure. This account of kids trick or treating is very funny! "What's it going to be pop, candy or your front window?" Cracks me up. Glad you enjoyed it. :-)
cschoon1213 2 years ago
Always associated this song with Christmas. Ain't Christmas for me 'til I hear four songs: Nat Cole's "Christmas Song", "Blue Christmas" by Elvis, "Little Saint Nick" by The Beach Boys and this. Merry Christmas!
expenguin67 2 years ago 2
Merry Christmas to you too and I also like the old song " Do You Hear What I Hear" !.
Peace and Love,
~~~ Chuck
cschoon1213 2 years ago