Avatar Remix - A.V.A.T.A.R. (Anglos Valiantly Aiding Tragic Awe-inspiring Races)
Uploader Comments (lewistonvideomaker)
Top Comments
-
interesting interpretation. we were not actually trying to make a statement about violence as a tactic in justice struggles. violence is just a key visual way in which one's agency to make change is signified in many films. in all of these films, that agency consistently belongs to white people. in reality, of course, people of color have been central agents of change in their own liberation movements through non-violent as well as armed resistance.
-
"Through -your- eyes." "Yes, boss." "strange and exotic people"
Ouch. This is painful to watch, and so very necessary.
All Comments (54)
-
@theshow2k8 history would not debase itself by reflecting anything of the sort
-
The "It is our destiny to save these people" dude at 3:11 looks a lot like Stephen Harper
-
@theshow2k8 And as with anyone in that kind of situation, power given can be abused.
-
Colonialism is not responsible for the exchange of the ideas and techniques. That's the goddamn printing press, which you should be thanking the Chinese for by the way. Colonialism is responsible the systemic exploitation of developing countries, the byproduct being short term growth. In it's nature a unsustainable affair, the colonialist hightailed it out when they weren't making ends meet. That left a lopsided system to fail and the people who relied on it to suffer.
-
History reflects the fact that whites were looked upon as gods to most poor races and in most cases,were asked to help.
-
Colonialism was very good for the most part.It helped many people and freed them from their primitive ways where many would die because of the lack of understanding of the world around them.
Most of the third world would not be where it is now and almost all would be dead if it were not for the Western world.
-
Hollywood attempts to justify colonialism at every turn. Even so called "pro-native" films end up merely putting forward the same contrivances. Instead of "we have to control the natives to help them" it's "their predicament is entirely their own fault, nevermind how we violently exploited them." In the end, it is the sad attempt of western society to live with itself after having fucked over the world for centuries. It's goddamn destructive.
Including The Last King of Scotland doesn't make any sense, as that movie is more about the meddling of a misguided outsider, and Gran Torino not so much either, as, IMO, it's much more about a mentorship relationship that happens despite race issues, IMO.
OTOH, Tears of the Sun is dead on, especially since it came out near Hotel Rwanda, making the contrast very obvious.
sxeptomaniac 5 months ago
@sxeptomaniac thanks for your comments. i appreciate the feedback.
lewistonvideomaker 5 months ago
I don't quite understand why Gran Torino has been spliced in, it doesn't seem to fit the mold of the Avatar storyline for me, that's more about a very solitary man reconnecting with those around him and passing on a legacy to someone who appreciated and listened to him.
mewtiny 8 months ago
@mewtiny We tried to emphasize imagery, not story line (though that's certainly important). The images, perspective through which a story is told, and assignment of agency is consistent in these movies. Your summary of Gran Torino is valid but also does not refute the analysis presented. The white protagonist (Clint) finds himself surrounded by exotic other (Hmong families) and is awe-struck by their tragedy and beauty. He adopts the cute kids as his own and sacrifices himself to save them.
lewistonvideomaker 8 months ago 7
I agree that the editing distracted from the point of the video. I would love some narration or a narrative a little more coherent. Otherwise it is a good point to recognize.
thoreauberon 8 months ago
@thoreauberon thank you for the feedback. for a film deconstruction with narration (inter-titles), i suggest "300 this is revisionism", which is the first video i made of this genre. for this AVATAR Remix, i didn't want to intervene with anything more than edits of the original content. no extra sound, titles, or voice-over. the commentary would remain strictly in the edits and require more work on the viewer's part to make meaning of the repetitions.
lewistonvideomaker 8 months ago 3