♪♫ My thoughts on Noel Gallagher/Beady Eye/Coldplay/Radiohead (Part 2)

There will be plenty of you who don't give a rats ass about my opinions, but I've just decided to do this blog in response to the emails I receive every day from the people and subscribers who keep asking me what I think about such things. If you couldn't care less what I think, then don't watch my video.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Oasis
• Beady
• Eye
• Noel
• Gallagher
• Peter
• Last
• georgiarose16
• Coldplay
• Radiohead

[domogenesisqwertz]

i love noel, but you keep going on about if you are a musician you'd gravitate more toward him and that is generally true, given the fact that his songs are really easy to learn and play, but if you we're a real musician you'd give each of those bands the credit they deserve and try to look into their music. if you stick to those same old 5 chords that oasis/noel have been using for decades you will never progress. and you want to become better, don't you? no hate intended btw, love your stuff.

[georgiarose16]

@domogenesisqwertz I hear you and agree with a lot of that. But remember, although being able to play an Ebmsus4dim#12 transition to a Bmsus411 might make you a great guitarist, it does not mean you are going to be a great song writer as a result. Some people are too intent on demonstrating their technical skill at the expense of the song. John Lennon didn't need to resort to that for Imagine. It really depends on what you define as 'becoming better'.

[mp15ish]

Radiohead is "crap"....?..thats when I stopped listening, cuz thats when you lost all credibility.

[georgiarose16]

@mp15ish byeee. My opinion. You're entitled to yours.

[subsahara121]

Beady Eye just give it time and judge them on the next album first album was a bit of a rush but if Oasis had put out the Roller people would love it. I think there is a lot of ppl following the media on the idea they can't do anything without Noel. Technically I rate Andy and Gem far better as musicians. Then Noel is left handed and plays the guitar right handed. Odd man for doing that but best songwriter we had in 20 years.

[georgiarose16]

@subsahara121 I agree with some of what you say. I agree Beady Eye's album was rushed. I agree Gem and Andy are great musicians and technically superior to Noel. I don't think though they come even close in the songwriting stakes though. I don't think even their best songs come close to Noel's. And personally, I think The Roller is Beady Eye's worst song.... but that's just me. I know Noel likes the song though, so go figure. I do hope they release a great 2nd album though.

[georgiarose16]

@TheLordbanjo I don't want to 'understand' music my friend. I want to listen to it. There's a difference.

[Blackicefairy]

I agree I love if a had a gun.

[MarkyMarkTheLad]

I prefer Beady Eye cus it's rock n' roll, as Noel it's a bit dancey but i still love Noel. Also i play bass an guitar so i am a musician of a small degree :P

[Robertotheredduran]

Im a massive fan of both radiohead and oasis. In my opinion noel and thom yorke, although very different in song writing styles, are as close as this generation has to a modern day lennon or mcartney. Thom yorke is an insane talent, check out him playin "The Clock" acoustically. Everyones entitled to their own opinion and to each their own, but as a music fan and if u like noels acousic stuff you should defo check out thom yorke's acoustic songs. no way can they be classed as crap.

[Robertotheredduran]

Good point on gravitating towards noels music more so than beady eye if u have an interest in playing music yourself. But to write radiohead off as crap is outrageous. Even if u dont like radiohead i recommend you go listen to the acoustic version of "There there". Just as good if not better than any of noels acoustic numbers. also check out the acoustic verisons of go to sleep, i might be wrong, gagging order, and tell me you still think radiohead are "Crap".

[c0bbl3rs]

What is the meaning of your ID username? GeorgiaRose16 seems a tad unusual for a bloke?

[vincent37lam]

@wwrjd1523 I also thought that was obvious