Prelude from Bach Cello Suite in G on Clavichord
Uploader Comments (SFChristo)
Video Responses
All Comments (87)
-
For example, in what is the ninth bar in my score and begins about about 0:35, you play the E with your left pinky and C# with your right middle as you ought; but when you come back down you could have ended the descent striking A with your left thumb and thus free the right hand to play GF#E and so on.
-
I find your choice of sustain and attention to both hands even where the left is not required to be very tasteful; however, I think you could stand to improve the legato in some parts by taking advantage of that very hand.
-
@csidearaque Thank you. I too think these go well on the clavichord. Want more?
-
When i watch someone play on clavichords, i always cringe and imagine the strings breaking and flicking them in the eye! This clavichord looks very safe against that problem, i wonder why not all were constructed like this beautiful clav?
Very nice performance thank you.
-
Simply put, a Clavichord strikes the strings, much like a Piano, while a Harpsichord actually plucks each string like a Harp or Guitar.
Anyway, I'm not meaning to be critical in anything but the supplemental sense, and for all I know you staccati where I've suggested otherwise were intentional; but I can see in your performance that you are certainly interested in anything besides boring and uncreative executions. So, I hope the thoughts are well-received as I intend them to be!
dolofonos 1 month ago
@dolofonos Hello, the understand the good intentions of your suggestions. So no problem. Right now the video won't load so I can't actually check out what you've suggested. For this piece, I tried to remember what it felt like to actually play it on a real cello back in 1995 and bring that into the performance. This was the most advanced I got on the 'cello. I appreciate the detail you bring to your comments. Thank you for listening!
SFChristo 1 month ago
@SFChristo I realized after posting, the significance of emulating the 'cello performance. I'll say your by far a better keyboardist than myself; but I could not pass the opportunity to suggest combining hands to improve legato, in general. I do see players on YouTube lift their hands many times when the alternative isn't obvious. Anyway, you're a model of true amateurism: keyboard, 'cello, composition, painting; it is very admirable. Thank you for sharing your accomplishments!
dolofonos 1 month ago
@dolofonos Thank you. I strive to be a good amateur and appreciate that some people are interested in my enthusiasms.
SFChristo 1 month ago
Very nice!! compliment!
RobertoFasciano 3 months ago
@RobertoFasciano Grazie!
SFChristo 3 months ago