Gary Numan featuring Marilyn Manson - Down In The Park (Live 1998)
Uploader Comments (GaryNumanAlbums)
Top Comments
-
While I'm not a fan of Marilyn manson, and I defaintly do not like anything Gary has done since Outland, I must say, this is a class act to let someone join you on stage for a song. That's a real class act right there, and even though I hate Marilyn Manson with a passion, I'll give it to him on this, as he didn't sound too bad.
5/5 stars, for the class act. This is what a real artist does, honor who you were influenced on, and then your idol welcoming you on stage.
-
I LOVE Marilyn Manson and Numan, so this is great :D
Video Responses
All Comments (163)
-
One of Numan's best tunes.
-
i LOVE Marilyn Manson and Numan, and this is SHIT.
-
Pretty cool of Numan to come on stage with Manson, that's gotta be a real honor to have someone you grew up listening to singing right next to you.
-
WHO THE FUCK IS BOOING MANSON? I'mma kick their ASSES.
-
cool,,,greatly done, sounds awesome...a thrill! i like manson somehow, controversial guy, sure, but a real good artist, whatever my stance to satanism may be...
-
@Northernmight they're both atheists, Gary never said it in the beginning I think but eluded to it in many songs like This Wreckage.
Nah Gary isn't technically a good singer- he would say that himself I'm sure. He has the kind of voice though that you know it's him as soon as you hear it.
-
@paintedship Thats a pretty good point! I love both versions, so yea. Both artists are quite alike too. Not about techniques, all about the expression. Art. Lets face it, neither Gary or Manson are really good singers, they are just very expressive, and thats what makes art. If you can feel it, you can feel it.
-
@Northernmight That robotic way Numan sings is what made him, fit that moog synth sound he had so well
-
marilyn can't sing, aff.
Hey GNA, check your messages, I sent you some audio of the NIN with Numan performances. Thougt you'd probally upload it since you got this up too.
LivingWorstNightmare 2 years ago
Thanks Nightmare, but I already had those a few weeks ago. I appreciate it and I am planning on uploading those, just not at the moment. I'm currently looking for more rareties and b sides from the Numa Records era along with some songs that were played live once or twice.
GaryNumanAlbums 2 years ago 2
Good Comment "Darklord2004"... Manson asked Numan to Guest on this L.A. gig and sing this.. There's So many 'Nay Sayers' around, Its 2010 and Numan's still here and some people just dont get it.. He's moved forward people.. its not the 80's anymore.. get over it!!
afriendcalled5iive 2 years ago
You're wrong. It was Numan that asked Manson to do this. This was recorded on the American Leg of the Exile tour.Read the video description.
GaryNumanAlbums 2 years ago
I have an interview on tape with Numan saying he was called by management of 'Brian Warner' in 1998 asking if 'Brian' could sing D.I.T.P. on stage with him, to which Numan says 'I didnt know who Brian Warner was!' and Eh, no he cant! Numan is then told who Brian is and then say's 'Yeah, of course' I checked the tape incase i'd got it wrong. maybe Numans tellin fibs.. i was just quoting!
p.s your G.N albums on you tube is amazing so thank u. Regards afriend called 5iive.
afriendcalled5iive 2 years ago 2
i was unaware of that, thnks for the info, I'll update the description soon.
Have a good day, and ignore these idiots who comments these videos marking everything down. They say you can't compare Manson and Numan, yet they do it too.
GaryNumanAlbums 2 years ago