Maeglin- Fallen Star
Uploader Comments (Encairion1)
All Comments (8)
-
Le hannon
-
Very well done! I think the music fits nicely. You've actually managed to make me feel sorry for Maeglin, which is *very* hard to do given Glorfindel is my favorite character. Beautiful! Though, I still say Maeglin had a choice, and should have never betrayed Gondolin like that, no matter what had happened to him.
-
Maeglin wasn't an evil person, he was just madly in love with idril and he desperatly wanted the only woman he could never have. Maeglin loved his uncle Turgon dearly and would never betray him but a promised Idril seemed to tempting to bare. He has no exuse for what he done but I can't help but feel so sorry for him, he through everthing away for the one he loved and she through him into mental torcher though ill admit that he wasn't right in the head, but no other elf had the life he did!
Maeglin's is one of the most tragic stories in the Silm. The art selection is great. Don't think the song fits very well though... for Maeglin, I would suggest Nirvana's "You Know You're Right".
robhoy1977 1 year ago 2
@robhoy1977 Thank-you for the comment :D Maeglin's story is one of the most tragic, and one of my favs. I do agree about the song, but you tube didn't let me use the original so I had to chose what they had to offer :( "You know You're Right" would have been an interesting choice, thank-you for the suggestion :D the one I had originally was "Angles" by Within Temptation. Thanks again!
Encairion1 1 year ago