Susan Boyle - Memory from Musical Cats Semi Final Britains Got Talent 2009 with Lyrics
Top Comments
All Comments (137)
-
She sounds very nervous. This is understandable. At her first performance, she had nothing to lose. Here, the world is expecting greatness and she feels her whole future is on the line, which, of course,it is. I'm pretty good under pressure, but I'm certain that my voice would shake a whole lot more than hers.
-
Standing Ovation
-
well, this may not have been her best, but it was a great attempt for someone like her, and I like her to, but i dont think this song fits her style really, I mean, if it was a different beautiful meaning song, she probably would've done better, I think personally she had stage fright at the beginning which wore off nearing the end, and she made a beautiful ending
-
that was beautiful :')
-
@ashleymarisa She's not exactly untrained. She had a private voice instructor, had singing lessons. That's not untrained.
-
@Moony479 Well, someone's got to lose. But, in my mind she didn't lose. She went on recording songs, made a career of it. That's not losing. In this song, Memory from Cats, I noticed that the first few notes were sour, or seemed sour to me. She lost out to Diversity. Maybe they made no mistakes, she made a few. Yet, again, she didn't exactly lose. Coming out second---that's a great thing.
-
@twiwonder I just got done listening to Elaine Page singing the same song, and I could tell the words. I couldn'y exactly make out the words when Susan sang it.o, yes, she could improve her diction. But, I felt for the most part she sanf beautifully.
-
@topsyluv I don't know if it's out of beat, but I did notice that the first few notews were sour, or seemed that way to me. Then she got back on track, and I thought she sang well.
-
@ArabellaTV I noticed her first few words were sour, or sounded sour to me. I am not an expert, though. I liked her singing Wild Horses better than this song. Yet, after the first few notes, she improved and I thought she sounded good. Again, WIild Horses, to me , anyway, was a better song for her.
-
@99IraqBaghdad99 I'm not doing a THUMBS DOWN, all in all she sang beautifully, yet didn't you notice the first few notes wewre sour. They sounded sour to me, anyway. Otherwise, she caught herself, got back on track and did a beautiful job. Maybe that's why people didn't like this video. Facts are facts. The first few notes were sour. That's no reason to use the F word. And I don't thinkl you were sorry at all in using the F word. If you were, you'd delete the message.
@ohsinnaman I think your comments are unfair and arrogant. Susan is untrained; of course, she wouldn't know how to give a dynamic performance. She has a beautiful voice and although she didn't know what she was doing, she was willing to put herself out there and take a chance. That's why she got such an opportunity. You shouldn't envy her for having guts. Also, how do you know what she understands? Twelve years of training doesn't make you an authority on music or Susan.
ashleymarisa 1 year ago 12
I would say she just sings average like a normal person and was really wobbly and bad at the start if you listened carefully. I like the orginial song 99% better than this one and honestly don't think shes that good. Everyone thinks different though, so you can't say that I am talking utter rubbish.
lulujv 1 year ago 10