Sergei Rachmaninoff - Prelude op 23 nº 5 in Gm (Valentina Igoshina)
Uploader Comments (karinamlz)
Top Comments
-
wonderful performance . . . she has plenty of power, and her performance would have been better highlighted on a longer Grand perhaps . . .. . I thought the "hidden melody" in the middle section was occasionally overpowered by the right hand . . . otherwise a most satisfying performance .. thanks for sharing
All Comments (29)
-
Creo que juega muy bien los tiempos y las entonaciones, pero eso no es todo, acompaña el tema con el cuerpo tal y como lo hacen por ejemplo Lang Lang y Zimerman, Es una excelente interpretación...no tengo más que decir.
-
This is the same speed if not slightly faster than Lisitsa. I like them both but Lisitsa in Korea is more accurate, I prefer her middle section interpretation in that too.
-
Wonderfull, big sense of phrases and great sound!!! Love it
-
Incredible thank you for sharing!
-
@andrew190495 -- I agree completely; as great as she is, I am not much of a fan of most of Lisitsa's performances. Most of the time, she plays everything far too fast -- this piece, for example -- and her accuracy suffers. Her interpretations can also be unusual and jarring. Just my opinion.
-
Valentina Lisitsa performs it masterfully
-
Pianists from the ex-USSR and named Valentina are the best : Valentina Igoshina, Valentina Lisitsa.
-
Beautiful performance. Love those ponderous bass octaves.
-
I don't understand what everyone sees in Lisitsa. Although she is an outstanding pianist with whom I could not be compared, I find her playing quite harsh, disjointed and unsettling to hear compared to most concert soloists. I listen to concert giants like Argerich and Ashkenazy, or even less well known performers such as Igoshina, and feel rather dissatisfied when I start to listen to Lisitsa afterwards. I don't see why she has to be "better" than everyone else. What makes her so special? In m
Thank you for sharing this video....Valentina is outstanding, and this particular performance shows her tremendous talent.
genialkg 2 years ago 2
yeah, I think exactly the same =)
karinamlz 2 years ago