"like wit, charm, sophistication, humor, lyricism and style."
Hey, sorry, I know everyone has different tastes and stuff, but to say that wit and humor is something Hamelin (ESPECIALLY in his compositions) "lacks", is to prove the multiverse hypothesis.
Or at least intelligent life on Mars... I mean, seriously?
No "lyricism" in the Little Nocturne? No "charm" in his Minuetto? No "humor" in the Campanella, or the Scarlatti homage? No "wit" in the triple etude or HR2 cadenza?
Do you mean his playing or his compositions? If compositions, your statement is rather ironic because the "charm" and especially the "wit" are probably the biggest and most attractive virtues of most of Hamelin's etudes and his HR2 cadenza.
Well I am a bit older at 56, but Stephen is the reincarnation of Rudolf Serkin as far as I am concerned. Needless to say I am going to look for any of piano CD's!
@aardvaark069 Yes, his playing of those miniatures displays a pianist of rare imagination. I was listening to another one of his albums, "Stephen Hough in Recital," alone in my room one quiet night and was completely taken away by the nuances in his interpretation that I've never heard before in pieces as hackneyed as the Chopin C-sharp minor Waltz of all things -- the voicing, the almost imperceptible variations in tempo, the phrasing. A pianist to treasure.
I've always thought Marc-André Hamelin uses too much pedal and plays things much too fast, because he can. (I'm not denying that he is an incredible virtuoso), but Hough is also more of an artist.
Hough has the most incredible technique. He has nothing to apologize for.
Stephen Hough has everything that Marc-André Hamelin has -- or more than enough of it, I should say -- and everything that Marc-André Hamelin lacks -- like wit, charm, sophistication, humor, lyricism and style.
Stephen Hough admittedly lives in a jaded, frightfully ignorant world over-crowded with great virtuosi starved for an appreciative audience, but Hough stands out in that world, and - like young RUPERT EGERTON-SMITH, a fellow Englishman - deserves far more acclaim than he receives.
This is pure awesomeness.
twooffour 2 months ago
@Pischnaholic
"like wit, charm, sophistication, humor, lyricism and style."
Hey, sorry, I know everyone has different tastes and stuff, but to say that wit and humor is something Hamelin (ESPECIALLY in his compositions) "lacks", is to prove the multiverse hypothesis.
Or at least intelligent life on Mars... I mean, seriously?
No "lyricism" in the Little Nocturne? No "charm" in his Minuetto? No "humor" in the Campanella, or the Scarlatti homage? No "wit" in the triple etude or HR2 cadenza?
twooffour 2 months ago
@aardvaark069
Do you mean his playing or his compositions? If compositions, your statement is rather ironic because the "charm" and especially the "wit" are probably the biggest and most attractive virtues of most of Hamelin's etudes and his HR2 cadenza.
twooffour 2 months ago
Well I am a bit older at 56, but Stephen is the reincarnation of Rudolf Serkin as far as I am concerned. Needless to say I am going to look for any of piano CD's!
drjjpdc 9 months ago
@aardvaark069 Yes, his playing of those miniatures displays a pianist of rare imagination. I was listening to another one of his albums, "Stephen Hough in Recital," alone in my room one quiet night and was completely taken away by the nuances in his interpretation that I've never heard before in pieces as hackneyed as the Chopin C-sharp minor Waltz of all things -- the voicing, the almost imperceptible variations in tempo, the phrasing. A pianist to treasure.
utubuser10 1 year ago
I've always thought Marc-André Hamelin uses too much pedal and plays things much too fast, because he can. (I'm not denying that he is an incredible virtuoso), but Hough is also more of an artist.
Hough has the most incredible technique. He has nothing to apologize for.
sanjosemike
sanjosemike 2 years ago
Am I English? Only by ancestry, but thank you I take your thought as a great compliment.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago
You know you sound really English. Are you English :)
SebastienLoong 2 years ago
Thank you kndly. I do urge you to listen to Rupert Egerton-Smith as well -- especially his Gaspard de la nuit.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago
Stephen Hough has everything that Marc-André Hamelin has -- or more than enough of it, I should say -- and everything that Marc-André Hamelin lacks -- like wit, charm, sophistication, humor, lyricism and style.
Stephen Hough admittedly lives in a jaded, frightfully ignorant world over-crowded with great virtuosi starved for an appreciative audience, but Hough stands out in that world, and - like young RUPERT EGERTON-SMITH, a fellow Englishman - deserves far more acclaim than he receives.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago