Re: Big Bang Question

A reply to Stoned Commander's videos about the Big Bang.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Big
• Bang

[6183078]

i dont think the big bang is true

[rocketmagnet]

Why?

[sleepingeye]

@YEyup

For the same reason that you want to know, why we wanna know the impossible.

[circle559]

i like the liquid explaination and it makes sense,,, some thing my obtain a critical mass in order for it to be formed sphericaly,, this would be related to compression, pressure and finaly heat,

[6183078]

i belive that it the universe expands and then gravity make all matter come back into one peace then it expand then it all comes back to one peace like a never ending thing but, how the matter got in are universe was by a black hole in another universe the black hole made a opening in space were matter came in to are universe but i still dont know how all the universe started or how gravity started so i still belive in god , i have a spelling disability icant reallybut whatamthinking in words

[YEyup]

So many questions.. Why..

Was there a Big Bang...

Who or what created the Big Bang..

Who or What created the space where the Big Bang occured....

And so on ... Why do we wanna know the impossible?

[h8uall66]

And I completely agree. This is one of those things where a 500 character explanation simply will not do the subject justice. I think that I have explained the concept sufficiently in a general sense to disabuse stonedcommander of many of the misconceptions that he had. And that was really the whole point of my original comment.

[FredricF]

Yes, I understand that you try to generalize but, technically, if the singularity was a "central point" we are still in it, only the singularity expanded to become the universe we live in. The concept "outside the singularity" make no sense so calling it a "central point" makes no sense either.

The BB theory is in may ways mind-boggling because the physics, or rather the conditions where the physics apply, is so far from our experience that "common sense" is totally useless.

[h8uall66]

Yes, this is technically correct, but there is still a central point: The Big Bang Singularity. While it is true that we are describing an expansion of space-time, which your example describes more accurately, it is also true that I am merely trying to give a very generalized description.

[FredricF]

"So this tells us that there is a central point that they are all moving away from. "

No it does not. If every galaxy move away from all others no central point is required or even meaningful to talk about.

Think about it like dots on a balloon that is filled with air and stretched out. All dots move away from each other with no central point. The universe is like that (but three dimensional, of course).