Bobby Jindal plays politics; is an embarrassment to Louisiana

If someone questioned the patriotism of the Republican governors who have said that they will turn down portions of the federal stimulus money intended for their states, I would have a hard time arguing with them.

Hey, if the Republicans can accuse the Democrats of being unpatriotic when they were in the minority, isn't turnabout fair play? But, actually, the Democrats would have far more basis to make their charge than the Republicans ever did. During the second term of the Bush administration, Republicans often questioned the patriotism of Democrats who sought to have a timetable for troop withdrawals included in Iraq-funding legislation. The White House called the party "Defeatocrats" and accused Democrats of advocating "surrender dates." Such charges were quite disgusting, since, clearly, the Democrats in Congress were laying out a vision of what they thought was best for the United States, not trying to do harm to their own country. Providing a competing vision for the nation's best course of action is not unpatriotic, especially given that it was the disastrous policies and execution of the Bush administration in Iraq that cost the U.S. dearly, in lives lost, lives ruined, money wasted, and respect in the world squandered. Advocating a change was a patriotic thing to do.

The same logic does not apply to the Republican governors passing up money from the stimulus package. In doing so, they are affirmatively taking action that is not in the best interests of their constituents, all for political gain. For example, on Meet the Press yesterday, Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana told David Gregory that he would turn down $100 million from the federal government to extend lapsed unemployment benefits for out-of-work Louisiana citizens. (A transcript of the show is available here.) Jindal claimed that to accept the money would require the state to raise taxes on businesses to fund the program after it expires in three years. Which is, of course, completely untrue, as Gregory pointed out, quoting the Democratic U.S. Senator from Louisiana, Mary Landrieu. Jindal responded that the word "permanent" was in the legislation, which meant he had to turn down the money.

This exchange demonstrated how dishonest and baldly calculating the Republican governors are in turning down federal stimulus money. With the economy in crisis (in January alone, nearly 600,000 jobs were lost, leaving the unemployment rate at 7.6 percent), Jindal's job isn't to play politics, it is to aid those in his state who are in trouble. He has an obligation to help his unemployed constituents who would have been saved, maybe from homelessness, maybe from hunger, by the extended benefits. States open and close programs all the time. Even if Jindal was right (which I doubt), that a "permanent" change was needed, what would stop the state from repealing the "permanent" change in three years through state legislative action? Is he really suggesting there is no way to undo the program, ever? And that it is good policy to allow his citizens to suffer needlessly?

If Jindal's game-playing wasn't so damaging to the people of his state, it would be entertaining in its transparency. But Jindal revealed how he views things, even if it was inadvertent, when he said, "My job is to represent Louisiana's taxpayers." No, Gov. Jindal, your job is to help all of your citizens, not just the ones currently paying taxes. When you throw in that virtually every Jindal answer defaulted to the right-wing talking point of him believing that lowering taxes is the way to get through the severe recession, there is no doubt what Jindal was up to. He was playing politics, branding himself and his party in an effort to return to power, all at the expense of the people of his state.

From a political point of view, I applaud the pigheaded opposition of GOP governors like Jindal and Mark Sanford of South Carolina. While they may govern safe red states, associating Republicans with doing nothing during a crisis is certainly political gold for the Democrats. But with things so tenuous now, and with people genuinely hurting, I cannot sit back and enjoy the political self-destruction, knowing that real people in real trouble will be damaged by the political game-playing of the Republicans.

When Republican governors put scoring political points over aiding their fellow Americans during a time of crisis, are they acting in a patriotic manner?
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mitchell-bard/are-gop-governors-who-tur_b_16926...

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• Bobby
• Jindal
• president
• Obama
• speech
• countdown
• with
• Keith
• olbermann
• hardball
• Chris
• Matthews
• state
• of
• union
• response
• stimulus

[DameDiabolique]

Fuck Bobby Jindal... He and these other governors that reject stimulus money has NO SHOT in 2012 because the ads Obama will run will be "Bobby Jindal rejected stimulus money helps working families who lost their jobs..." And they will put up a picture of a struggling mom and her babies or the thousands of workers lined up at the Unemployment Office... Plus he lied in his Republican Response speech... Oooo...

[jhaddicks]

Kick Bobby Jindal's ass out of office!

[machine1600]

JINDAL IS NO BETTER THAN LANDRIEU. BOTH ARE FKN CROOKS.. HE'S THE LITTLE INDIAN THAT WANTS TO BE........................ PRESIDENT AND PEACEMAKER OF THE WORLD. OBAMA HAS CLOSE TIES WITH INDIA FOR A REASON.

[loonmaniac]

Does Pyush Jindal own any suits that actually fit him?

[yamahargs]

@roostertrigger agree but do not forget to mention your polarized station also. FOX or OUTFOXEEEEDDD...Did you want the documentary?

[yamahargs]

Idiot. Does he even know that Republicans core values revolve around that. More states power, less federal govt? The money is not for him. Is for the ppl of his state!

[yamahargs]

Idiot. Does he even know that Republicans core values revolve around that. More states power, less federal govt?

[prplhze2000]

Louisiana has the most solvent unemployment fund in the country. Hmmm...think they might know what they are doing? 

[blacktop1177]

Jindal for President!!! .. Dont pay much attention to the media b/c they are all liberals...It's clear Jindal is wayyy smarter than the idiots with the media...

[roostertrigger]

when is MSNBC going off the air?

[StoogeWatcher]

Democrats ARE unpatriotic because they don't pay taxes. Joe Biden said so himself.

[StoogeWatcher]

You wanted to kick out Bobby Jindal, yet you have no problem with William Jefferson.