Wayne Marshall plays Messiaen at the BBC Proms
Uploader Comments (JFSnail)
All Comments (37)
-
I can't believe the BBC put this out with the organ is such an appalling state. It is practically unplayable.
-
@JontyTrain That's because this organ had SERIOUS winding problems at the time this was recorded. This was before the Mander rebuild, and it is since much better.
-
Have a listen to the Oliver Latry proms performance of this, the organ has gone up about a quarter tone, the chorus sounds totally knackered here.
-
Marshall is amazing but the organ sounds absolutely horrific!
-
Mr. Marshall is a splendid virtuoso. Messiaen's works call for color, flexibility and imagination; his own recordings of his work bears this out, and this was presented with great style.
That the artist was handicapped with an acoustically dead room and a wheezing instrument is not his fault. He had to work with what was dealt him. The self-appointed YouStoopid guardians of style might want to consider such conditions.
-
What was the commentator talking about? The sounds were terrible!
-
Still with the winding problems??? just saaaags at the end
-
A truly marvelous performance from my old tutor! Especially as this poor old heap hadn't been restored at the time. Well done :-)
-
@simonjp90 yes, it is you
-
@bvsiness Got to agree with that. And I was at the RAH for this performance. It was an electrifying effort on a very tired instrument.
One more thing. The Related Videos that are popping up seem to focus on the Marshall part rather than Messiaen or RAH. Maybe you should re-arrange your Tags? ;-)
a55b47 2 years ago
well, there might be a few disappointed people who wanted to see the 'other' Wayne Marshall.
Also love the way the voiceover by well known BBC journalist called the organ a 'machine' at the end of the clip, had to keep that in! :-)
JFSnail 2 years ago