Vivace, from Organ Trio Sonata III (Bach, BWV 527) - Original Piano Arrangement
Uploader Comments (zeryx28)
Top Comments
-
The beamed double 32nd + 16th figure is a beaut'!
-
wonderful. simply wonderful. greetings from mcmaster.
Video Responses
All Comments (15)
-
It's wonderful
wow :D :-) XD
-
@zeryx28 piano? I thought this was harpsichord. although I love this piece on organ your arrangement sounds very good!
-
@phrtphkbrlz very clear but alot of notes are omitted/changed! Thus harmony is no longer original!
-
The sound is very clear, probably the best I've heard so far..
Hope you will do more trio-sonate of Bach like this.
..may the force be with you!
-
Wow.
-
@zeryx28 I understand that this is piano transcription but the impt thing about transcriptions is that it has to be convincing for the new instrument(s) and without alterations of Bach's original harmony. By transposing and omitting notes, the harmony has changed completely. The crux about the trio sonatas is the freely moving soprano, alto and bass parts; Bach wrote for organ as he didn't want to be restricted with notes reachable by 2 hands. I suggest you assign the soprano part to violin.
-
Brilliant!
Alot of notes are missing/transposed! Try not to alter Bach's original notes just for sake of playing with 2 hands. This is afterall for organ.
mtv565 11 months ago
@mtv565 Thanks for your comment.
> Alot of notes are missing/transposed!
That is correct.
> Try not to alter Bach's original notes just for sake of playing with 2 hands.
But that was my intent ...
> This is afterall for organ.
Yes, and I have arranged it for piano.
I think what I would like to express is the challenges in arranging for piano something that is not and that there is beauty in overcoming these challenges and exploring the limits of two-handed playing. :)
zeryx28 11 months ago
hey you should arrange an organ piece or something for the orchestra
something really loud like bwv686 muhaha
or the great fugue
reinux 1 year ago
@reinux Hahaha we'll see. :3 I already have plans for my next composition for SFUCO hahaha.
zeryx28 1 year ago