Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold
Uploader Comments (benstox)
Top Comments
-
I prefer Thorin's version.
-
@pnstewart Just to clarify: of course I did not write the text. Everyone knows this poem. It's one of the most famous songs in Tolkien. Someone asked me however, "Where did the music originate from?" For fun I wrote this admittedly pretentious melody to sing Tolkien's poem to. Please read things on the internet carefully before you call someone a liar.
All Comments (73)
-
This is great! I prefer this version much more to the one that was in the movie trailer. It was too "hollywoodized" for me. Benstox' version is much more how I imagined it to be when I first read to book. :)
-
Tolkien, who was Tridentine rite supporting Catholic, would probably have loved this. Shame about all the movie trailer fanboys disliking this version.
-
@benstox I would love that. My email is maelcaedmon [at] yahoo [dot] com
-
watch out for that flaming guys...
-
a different sounding version of this same song is sung by the Dwarves in The Hobbit movie.
-
Awesome. It may not be done by the dwarves but still this one gives me a better image of the land and the tale.
Amazing! I would love to get the PDF if you are willing to publish it. Same goes for the regular mp3.
diademchi 1 day ago
@diademchi Thank you. Yes, you're welcome to them. Message me your e-mail address and I can send them.
benstox 20 hours ago
Thank you. I have often felt that the Dwarves' love of gold and hearth took on a nearly religious cast. This expresses that sentiment quite well. Also very nice that you didn't fall into the trap of making it sing-song like many renditions do.
I wish I had a better knowledge of Plainchant to recognize the tones.
amhlaidgh 1 week ago
@amhlaidgh Glad you enjoyed it. Actually, a friend recently gave me a 'cheat sheet' that he had used as an organist in a French seminary, outlining the musical characteristics of the 8 tones. It's quite interesting in that it also gives short one- or two-word descriptors for the feeling of each of them. Mode I for instance is called "grave paix" and Mode VIII is "perfectus pleinitude". It's helped to keep the modes distinct in my head. If you want I can send it to you as an excel spreadsheet.
benstox 1 week ago