PZ Myers proves the Quran is correct

This video is brought to you by http://www.sibawayinstitute.com The video is presented by Nabeel Alkhalidy who uses a classical commentary on the verse related to the embryological stages that some non Muslims are using to claim that the Quran is scientifically incorrect.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• miracle
• atheist
• Aristotle
• God
• Allah
• PZ
• Myers
• embryology
• mudgha
• alaqa
• scientific
• learn
• arabic
• studies
• grammar
• nahw
• sarf
• course
• online
• class
• learning
• morphology
• quran
• islam
• muslim
• sibaway
• institute
• Qur'an
• Quran
• Koran
• tafseer
• tafsir
• lexicography
• Prophet
• Muhammad
• word
• choice
• science

[LearnQuranicArabic]

I got plenty of criticisms from those who don't know Arabic, which I expected because people just don't want to believe. can somebody please produce a video response or something.

[TheRationalizer]

I note that yet again you add a word in brackets as if it were in Arabic.

"made [from] the bones flesh"

If only Allah had thought to write MIN then it would have been perfect wouldn't it? But no, the man from sibway institute had to write that word in in brackets to pretend it is in the Arabic.

In essence though I didn't understand your argument. You still said THEN the bones were clothed in flesh.

And why were you not complaining for years that the BONES THEN FLESH miracle claim was wrong?

[LearnQuranicArabic]

@TheRationalizer min would indicate that when the bones form, the mudgha will stay a mudgha in the process of bone development. Also, obviously bones can't be clothed if they are not there and that is why "then" is used.

[robbegx]

@LearnQuranicArabic The amount of apologetics Hamza (and now you) give us to swallow is piling up and I'm telling you man, you guys are making complete fools of yourselves (I'm also referring to the video discussion between you and TheRationalizer). Keep changing meanings (or picking interpretations that suit you, ignoring everything else), truth will prevail. Religion is bound to fail over time, and you guys are just helping with these pathetic attempts of defense.

[tsip29]

@ConsideringPhlebas

does it matter if we do not know Arabic. it has been transelated by islamic scholars who do know Arabic. and according to him they are all wrong.

as you said it is a bullshit argument. and we have to hear it over and over and over again

[faro0485]

The verse is indicating that it's getting bigger, but the use of izama is telling us that it is becoming elongated as it gets bigger. And that without the bones, it would be like a blob.

[robbegx]

@LearnQuranicArabic You got plenty of criticism not because we "just don't want to believe", but because you make a case as unconvincing as it gets. Here you are, claiming the Quran was right all along - after it had been pointed out it was wrong - while up until then EVERYBODY assumed the verse indicated delay. In fact, Adnan 'Thumma' Rashid was asking if Aristotle specifically mentions the sequence, as this was regarded something unique to the Quran.

[bubka]

Of the three primary germ layers (ECTODERM, ENDODERM, MESODERM) that produces tissues, then organs, and systems. Bone forms from MESODERM, MESODERM forms after ECTODERM (skin and CNS) and ENDODERM (gut, respiration).

[mythinktube]

It really must be a life long commitment to come up with the mental gymnastics required to make the logical fallacies in the Qu'ran fit with science and rationality

[robertmike57]

Must hurt having to retranslate your chicken scratchings to make your dirty filthy book conform to what is now known.

[BachTantra]

the miraculous changing of the meaning and translation of the quran to fit modern science again....so its not a clot anymore?

[GodzApostle]

@hefty1986 it absolutely does form together as embryology has shown and the quran says exactly that.

there is no ambiguity in the Qur'an in terms of embryology.

[LuqmanNaq]

@LearnQuranicArabic The miraculous ambiguity of the Quran.