Anna Netrebko as Lucia di Lammermoor (Wien 2009)
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (154)
-
There's somewhat lacking in her performance though.
-
Great!
-
@tombwomb I am reminded about an "infamous" statement apparently made by Melba - "give 'em muck!" It would seem that even though this was 100 years ago she must have been looking into the future with audiences made up of people like yourself. lol.
-
@verdinfishy Absolutely. A lovely singer, quite a charming a sweat women, and I rather like her in certain things, but a super star?? Please! 30 yrs. ago this would have been a good Adele or Susanna for NYC Opera, basta.
-
@TheVaughan5 I couldn't agree with you more.Nowadays these over-rated,over-hyped pseudo-divas are being foisted off on an unsuspecting and unfortunately largely ignorant public as the "greatest of all times." Dare to criticize them & you are vilified.But how do you explain to a generation of opera lovers who never heard the likes of Sutherland,Moffo,Scotto live,in their primes,that their beloved "super stars" would, 40 yrs. ago, have been at best barely adequate utility singers.
-
just love theatre and music. its an imperfect art form that strives for those magical nights. she is bettee than many.
-
you sit in your dingy flats, no career to speak off, living vicariously through divas who actually couldnt give a flying anyhting about your rubbish opinions. so...shes not perfect..not many singers...read..no singers are... its a collaborative and theatricaart form, requiring many things, many of which netrebko brings. im not in love with her, no crush, i
-
@Pathetikos It's very depressing that audiences in places like Vienna, Milan, Venice etc. that used to be discerning are happy to accept almost anything that's on offer these days, no matter how bad it often is. 30 odd years ago this medicore performance would be treated for what it is, today it's cheered - proof how standards are at an all time low.
-
che schifo!!
-
@Pathetikos Hmm.. that was really flat...It seems that her producers have no mercy to her by pushing her to sing the role after recent giving birth to her child.On your place I wouldn't be so judgmental.Let's say she had a day off.
- Loading comment...
Good God, that E-flat was horrific!
Elisabetta611 2 years ago 14
Love that final E flat flat flat....
sour7lemon 2 years ago 8