Uploader Comments (ClearValleyFrost)
Top Comments
-
Both versions are pure gold. Stop hating, I'm a huge fan of Modest mouse yet I still like this.
All Comments (154)
-
I...kinda like it. And that's coming from a major Modest Mouse fan.
It doesn't have the exact same tune or anything, but it's still a good song.
-
It sort of ceases to be a cover when the tune and beat are completely different. I love this version, but I just don't think you can take someone else's lyrics, throw it into your own song, and call it a cover..
-
Great song. I Don't really care for modest mouse much at all, but still a great song.
-
What... What the fuck did he do to Tiny Cities Made of Ashes? The way this guy does this just does not work with Modest Mouse, I'm sorry.
-
why do people insist on molesting modest...., its one of those things that when touched in anyway turns to meaningless shit
-
@Loveracious (terribly underrated post)
-
Look look - this is not a one off cover. Mark Kozelek is a huge Modest mouse fan and this is just one of the songs from a whole album of Modest Mouse re-interpretations. Some Mouse fans might not like the style but the complete body of work is an interesting and considered set of interpretations from a respectful fan. Of all the covers in the world these ones do not need slagged.
-
Wats this song about?
-
I'm a fan of Modest Mouse. I'm a fan of Mark Kozelek's work. "Have You Forgotten" is one of my favorite songs of the past 25 years. But this cover comes off as a bit contrived. The lyrics sound forced to Kozelek.
-
it's called deconstruction. and every good cover does it. Hendix doing all along the watch tower? good bands re-interpret. bad bands cover.
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Honestly, I usually like covers, but this cover is horrible.
CK3890 8 months ago
@CK3890 you're horrible
ClearValleyFrost 8 months ago 31