American Idol 7 Top 6 Elimination of Carly Smithson 04/23

Carly Smithson's Elimination. Short write up at http://tinyurl.com/6l7gff

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• elimination
• american
• idol
• 04/23
• carly
• smithson
• top
• syesha
• mercado
• results
• entertainment

[e6e678910]

where is the sound?

[giganticgreen]

there's a sound. make sure your speakers are up.

[rubiitvxqsuju]

Simon looked so sad :(

i'd be SO disspointed if BROOKE OR JASON manages to stay next week, unless if they pull of something amazing

[giganticgreen]

If the "popularity contest" as what Randy has mentioned continue next week, then Syesha might be the next cast-off.

[shannon372565784]

i was mortified when i heard she was going home, but the flip side is look how great jennifer hudson turned out once she went home! she was in dreamgirls! so shes gonna have a huge career ahead of her and this is not the last time you will here the name CARLY SMITHSON

[irishsweethearttx]

2:42 she looks stunning. I miss those irish eyes, I will miss her in general. PLEASE COME BACK CARLY SMITHSON ! :D

[triamera28]

Carly is such a brilliant and great singer...

She is so pretty..

I LOVE YOU CARLY!!!

GO CARLY!!!!!

GO CARLY!!!!

[JBArchieFan101]

no offense but in my opinion syesha or brooke should have been the botton 2

[spashley16]

she was the best one on american idol 7... she is my idol... Is such a joke for her to be leaving so soon.. not fair at all...

[cbotten106]

No but Ryan's pause before announcing the "result" certain was.

[shannihan]

I hope she sing "Alone" by Heart on the tour. If you go to the official myspace done by her family, she says "I'm gonna sing Alone. I never got to do it on the show, but hopefully I'll get to do it on the tour." when you play Alone on the top left-hand corner of the page. I know she sang it during Hollywood week, but I think she meant the finals. :)

[cbotten106]

Carly's going to get three songs on the tour so if you've got the money and the stomach to sit through a couple of hours of "the others" then it would be cool to see her sing live. Supposedly her set is going to be Come Together (Beatles cover), Crazy On You (Heart cover) and Bring Me To Live (an Evanescence cover). Sounds like a good set for Carly.

[L00king4LOVE247]

She has the best personality and the best voice ever !!!! I still am trying 2 get over that moment. That shouldn't have been. I can't wait to buy Carly's album and see her on tour.

WAY TO GO CARLY !!!!! I <33 YA !!!

[cbotten106]

Carly is truly a special talent and I suspect in time a whole lot of people we come to this conclusion.