Thomas Tallis - The lamentations of Jeremiah
Uploader Comments (stigekalder)
Top Comments
-
How can anyone call this boring? It's one of the most beautiful choral works in existence.
All Comments (26)
-
I think the GeeGees should have recorded this. It could easily have transposed to three voices in harmony. Tho they could have had trouble with the latin.
-
Thx for the upload
PS the visual fade at the end was quite striking to me too : )
-
Wonderful stuff. If you went to sleep in this , or singing anything , then may I suggest that you take more water with it , or just drink less !
-
I sang this a few times, behind the cross during the Good Friday service, as the congregation would approach for veneration and prayer. Put the music in the proper setting and it's far from boring. It's unusual to see an outpouring of emotion from English (mostly) middle class people, but this did it!
In my opinion, it works better with all men's voices, e.g. ATTBB. The boys tend to sound to soft. The version here is also a bit weak on the middle part, which is probably the most interesting.
-
Admirers of the lamentations may be interested to know that since most of the books of the Bible do not have their own names in the original Hebrew, they are called by the their first word
so this book is called in Hebrew "How" - "Eicha" (or The scroll of How, since it is usually read from a scroll).
Btw the word "eicha" begins also withe the letter "Aleph" despite the spelling differences in English - obviously it is the same consonant.
-
@Horza1972ex if your singing Tallis all the time then one can be forgiven for nodding off in the ranks.
-
@molealto Wait, so is this SATTB, or SAATB, then?
-
Yup, I reckon a 3rd up.
-
Almost equally lovely is the great Ave, Dei Patris Filia.
At 5:02 the basses have a D, but they're singing an E, right? :P
Gallahaut 1 year ago 4
@Gallahaut
Yes you're right. And D would sound terrible. Must be an error in the score. Is possible as I did not make it myself ;-) Thanks for pointing that out, have a happy new year !
stigekalder 1 year ago 3
tallis can be sublime, but isn't he a bit boring here? I remember singing this once and we were so bored of the same dull harmoies we could fall asleep in the stalls. This version is, I think, a third up? it doesn't harm it... mighty low notes for the basses, we sung it as written... AATTB, I think... even more boring! :-D
amatorynumber 1 year ago
@amatorynumber
If this piece bored you, there is only the choir or the conductor or both to blame, not the composer... Agree that the same basic mood is consistent all thru the piece, but considering the text that can be justified. Think that the change to homophonic towards the end (Jerusalem, convertere...) makes a strong impression; also the incredible modulation to G# in the last bar I will never forget. Documents that Jerusalem finally did convert.....
Best wishes, Niels
stigekalder 1 year ago 2