@MacXpert74: Agreed. More knobs are far better than less. I just think the industry as a whole has snapped it's collective fingers and has people focused on larger interfaces rather than the sound. These are the same people who balk at a small display or in this case, real knobs as being something needless. Tactile feel and analogue bandwidth cannot be replaced by a larger display and or plug-in compatibility. Advertising conditioning has a lot of people focused on the wrong things.
@paulwilliammeyer I agree that the sound is always the number 1 reason to choose a certain instrument. That's why I prefer real analog synthesizer to digital emulation. To some they sound the same, but I can still hear the difference. But besides the sound, I also find the traditional knob / slider interface much better than manipulating a virtual slider on screen. That's just not as quick or as intuitive.
@MacXpert74: I agree but I'll take it a step further. I could care less what the damn interface looks like. It's the SOUND that's crucial. Knobs are nice in real time for changes of course but if you gave me one knob and one 3X3 display and it sounded beautiful it wouldn't matter what the interface was. You have the ear or you don't.
@igig1970666 I have to disagree. Nothing beats the "hands on" experience of real hard-ware knobs and sliders. If they would make them with only a touch screen, you might as well just be using a software plug-in on your computer. The real fun of using a real synthesizer IS in the hardware knobs and sliders.
The designers should have put everything on one huge(touch) user frndly- screen.,the current,although retro design is just more complicated,... nice concept in retrospect! but in manifacture ..more expensive!
@salvadory yeah i know waldorf are mostly digital- i m just saying for the price thats ridiculous- id rather buy all analog or save a few grand and buy a waldorf- the solaris sounds no better to my ears- the only synth worth a few grand are the moog reissues
I'm not sure I can really tell how good of a VA it is, on a YouTube video. I'm waiting for the flac demos, on Johns' web site (ha ha, like I can afford it anyways).
@Keybern looks great- sounds like your typical digital va to me- pretty cool but not like the anlogue beast reissues so many are longing for- think id rather buy a waldorf (trk???) you know the big yellow one -much cheaper and sounds better!
I can't understand that the people behind this kind of events / synth exhibitions don't provide some extra line outs to which the reviewer can plug in so the audience can have a clearer listen. There's really a lot of noise on the background and it's completely ruining this preview.
@MacXpert74: Agreed. More knobs are far better than less. I just think the industry as a whole has snapped it's collective fingers and has people focused on larger interfaces rather than the sound. These are the same people who balk at a small display or in this case, real knobs as being something needless. Tactile feel and analogue bandwidth cannot be replaced by a larger display and or plug-in compatibility. Advertising conditioning has a lot of people focused on the wrong things.
paulwilliammeyer 5 hours ago
@paulwilliammeyer I agree that the sound is always the number 1 reason to choose a certain instrument. That's why I prefer real analog synthesizer to digital emulation. To some they sound the same, but I can still hear the difference. But besides the sound, I also find the traditional knob / slider interface much better than manipulating a virtual slider on screen. That's just not as quick or as intuitive.
MacXpert74 6 hours ago
@MacXpert74: I agree but I'll take it a step further. I could care less what the damn interface looks like. It's the SOUND that's crucial. Knobs are nice in real time for changes of course but if you gave me one knob and one 3X3 display and it sounded beautiful it wouldn't matter what the interface was. You have the ear or you don't.
paulwilliammeyer 21 hours ago
@igig1970666 I have to disagree. Nothing beats the "hands on" experience of real hard-ware knobs and sliders. If they would make them with only a touch screen, you might as well just be using a software plug-in on your computer. The real fun of using a real synthesizer IS in the hardware knobs and sliders.
MacXpert74 2 months ago 2
The designers should have put everything on one huge(touch) user frndly- screen.,the current,although retro design is just more complicated,... nice concept in retrospect! but in manifacture ..more expensive!
igig1970666 2 months ago
@salvadory yeah i know waldorf are mostly digital- i m just saying for the price thats ridiculous- id rather buy all analog or save a few grand and buy a waldorf- the solaris sounds no better to my ears- the only synth worth a few grand are the moog reissues
salvadory 1 year ago
@salvadory: The Waldorf synths are either fully digital or hybrid synthesizers. Talking about "analogue" beasts.
albedoshader 1 year ago
I'm not sure I can really tell how good of a VA it is, on a YouTube video. I'm waiting for the flac demos, on Johns' web site (ha ha, like I can afford it anyways).
klockwerk1 1 year ago
@Keybern looks great- sounds like your typical digital va to me- pretty cool but not like the anlogue beast reissues so many are longing for- think id rather buy a waldorf (trk???) you know the big yellow one -much cheaper and sounds better!
salvadory 1 year ago
I can't understand that the people behind this kind of events / synth exhibitions don't provide some extra line outs to which the reviewer can plug in so the audience can have a clearer listen. There's really a lot of noise on the background and it's completely ruining this preview.
Keybern 1 year ago 2