Oasis - Lyla (Noel On Vocals)

Oasis - Lyla (Noel On Vocals)

Category:

Music

Tags:

• oasis
• lyla
• noel
• on
• vocals
• demo
• liam
• gallagher

[skonfol]

Lyla sounds better with the Liam`s voice...

[dracodude7]

I personally think that Liam suits some particular songs like Wonderwall, Lyla, Supersonic .

But Noel has a beautiful voice suited for songs like, DLBIA, Little by Little (Beautiful), Let there be love (Common baby), Wish he sang Stop Crying your heart out .

But Both brothers are beautiful musicians , they deserve to live forever. Oasis lives forever.

[descono0cido]

@dracodude7 here ya go mate /watch?v=rKz5wxrA3nU

[yuka096385]

His voice doesn't much this song but I like his voice.

[JohnKulo]

@vitornoel13 Meh, I just don't like his voice anymore. He's a great frontman, but the voice is just so dry and dark. It just feels so lifeless now. I do like the Roller and Beat Goes On, I've listened to them, but they just don't do anything to me. And yeah, I agree, there's nothing he should regret, but I just wish his voice would've survived the time and his lifestyle, cause I think he had the best of voice of the 90's hands down.

[sheskat]

CHE ORRORE!

[vitornoel13]

@JohnKulo ´Still, Liam did some things to take care of his voice. He changed the way to sing and it´s not the same junkie he used to be. IMO he is still a great singer and i really can´t understand don´t like songs like Four Letter Word, Millionaire, Roller, Beat Goes On, Morning Sun, Bubble in a bullet. I really can´t and i´m sorry for you. The main point is that i don´t think he shloud have any regrets. But you can think whatever you want. And i´m not saying in a agressive way.Cheers

[vitornoel13]

@JohnKulo Well basicly we disagree about Beady Eye being a great band. I do and you don´t. And about the voice, you quoted some exceptions that can keep the voice in a high level. Although being a good singer isn´t only about achieving a high tone. In a general it is a age thing. Paul Mccartney can´t sing Oh Darling anymore, even Tyler is not the same singer he used to be, and he didn´t became a freaking saint that doesnt smoke and stuff.

[JohnKulo]

@vitornoel13 And besides Liam did not loose his voice because of aging, well it's not the main problem. It was his singing style. As much as I like Liam as a singer, he was not a talented singer, but had a great voice. Many times when singing live you can hear problems in his singing. A singing teacher would've helped a lot, like it did do James Hetfield. Surgery would've been the final option. I'm not saying he sucks, I just think it would be great if he could still sing like in the early days.

[JohnKulo]

Don't make this personal. Don't tell me I dont understand rnr, I do! I have listened to Beady Eye, live and studio, and I have tried to like it, but I just can't. I just can't make myself like it, because it's just not good IMO. I loved Liam in Oasis and I still think he's hell of a performer, but his voice is what made him so great to me. It is possible to save your voice; listen to RJ Dio from 60's to 2009. Steven Tyler same thing. Liam just didn't care, which is a shame.

[vitornoel13]

@JohnKulo i do agree he could do something to keep the voice better but it wouldn´t matter too much. The voice is worse now, mainly, because it´s a natural thing of age. The man is fourty now. And about being useless in Beady Eye it makes no sense. If you understand something about rock n roll´and check some videos live, like Isle of Wight or Rio de janeiro(that i went). That band is on fire, kept the Oasis level, one of the best at the moment. And prepare for the secnd album.

[JohnKulo]

@vitornoel13 He could've hired a singing teacher, change his singing pose or at least rest his throat better. He did not, and even kept smoking cigs and drinking. I'm not saying he should've sung less enthusiastic, I'm saying he should've done something to keep it good. He used all of his voice in the 90's, now it's useless in Beady Eye. They say it's better to burn than fade away, but Liam has burned and now he keeps fading away.