Ustvolskaya - Piano Sonata No. 5 (Part 1/2)
Top Comments
All Comments (18)
-
@bayreuth79 everything can be music, also noises.
-
Whoa, that sounded pretentious, but hey, still.
-
Ooh, this is pretty divisive in its response. I feel that's a testament to the validity of its existence. Though I welcome corollary!
-
You gave me hope! now i know even i can compose something people will listen to!
-
Great. Thanks for sharing this!
The pauses say as much as the notes
-
Great. Thanks for sharing this!
-
Pretentious nonsense. I'm not even sure this can described as music. I'm by no means musically unsophisticated- I appreciate the music of Schoenberg and Webern (well, some of it at least)- but this is just vacuous noise. In fact, atonal music is an oxymoron. For music to be distinguishable from mere noise it has to be in a tonal context, even if this tonal context is pushed to its limits, as in certain passages from 'Tristan' and later composers.
-
Aye, seems an excellent plan. I found this piece growing on me more and more as I listened to the second half of it, as well as some of her other pieces (I find myself particularly fond of her 6th sonata). Cheers. :)
-
no ,of course there are many
I just find it hard to accept or understand hers as something that is valid and that makes sense and that is rare with me as I am open to all kinds of music (contemporary(serial) baroque ,pop etc)
there is always the matter of taste ,like "I am not a fan of hers /his but I recognize his/her genius but with her...I am not even there..anyway I'll try listening to her more maybe something will change
This is pure genius. The only other modern composer I can think of with so unique a voice is Messiaen, and perhaps Scelsi. It's shocking how little-known she is.
TheRealLordRama 1 year ago 4
Seriously man, hats off for the continuous postings!
A genuinely unique composition...
HyneseyBoy 2 years ago 4