♫ The Coventry Carol (Collegium Vocale Gent) ♪
Uploader Comments (REV16665)
All Comments (31)
-
@margotlorena1 I don't. I treat smart arses like that, esp. the ones who accuse ME of being one. Good riddance to you!
-
@REV16665 why you treat people like that? I just told you twice what I meant with my comment yet you keep making fun of me, for no reason at all. you still dont understand what I wrote, I thought this was a placing for sharing opinions and experiences, but I guess not, I guess bashing and making fun of people is what your channel is all about, if you didnt understand what I said you could have asked me to elaborate further, to explain, but no, you try to appear smart. goodbye.
-
@margotlorena1 As originally written (and performed here), there are three vocal parts - soprano, tenor and bass. The minor 2nd you are talking about occurs in the final phrase of every verse, where the sopranos sing a sharpened 7th and the tenors don't. In this version, they only do it on the very last verse, at 2:33. You can hear versions by The Sixteen and maybe The King's Singers where they use the minor 2nd more.
-
@margotlorena1 So the person who commented "I know of a version with several minor seconds between alto and soprano... but I can't hear it here... on "young" should have been one" is calling ME a smart arse? That is ex-treme-ly funny! Thank you very much for that!!! (I've been laughing my socks off all day, you see...)
-
@REV16665 WTF man what do you have to be like that? completely twisting one's words to make you look smarter: I was talking of another version of this carol I know of, on the world young should have been a 2nd minor, but this is another version. I never said I was absolutely certain or anything, I was talking about the version the Cambridge singers sing, directed by John Rutter.
-
@margotlorena1 You appear to be very well-informed. Since you are absolutely certain that 'on "young" should have been one', you might as well announce to the world who composed this beautiful carol!
-
This is beautiful. On a completely unrelated note, that bloke on the far right is REALLY tall.
-
@franciskoerber I know of a version with several minor seconds between alto and soprano... but I can't hear it here... on "young" should have been one
This vid's AMAZING! One little question: Where'd you get the lyrics from? This appears to be 12th century or older, considering the styles as well as the spelling used. I know these lyrics exist, only I've never seen them in real life.
slashtiger1 2 weeks ago
@slashtiger1 Click any of the first four links under the video, and the lyrics will appear - as if by a miracle!
REV16665 1 week ago