Brahms: Rhapsody in G Minor Op. 79 no. 2
Uploader Comments (dhfeld)
Top Comments
-
I am going to play this for my audition!! YAY! :D
Rate this thumbs up if you like piano!!
-
right hand triplets too loud, few wrong notes heard. tempo changed to abruptly. melody not heard at times. dynamics not well done, especially when it is ppp. you do not understand the art of music yet you attempt on brahams?! you should go back and reread your music and interpret this rhapsody better.
All Comments (183)
-
@leunge0 ahh mate piss off its a bit too fast and dynamically challenged at times but all in all its a fairly decent attempt. what he's not allowed to attempt to play brahms because its not up to your standards? if youre going to post criticism, do it through a video of you playing it better.
-
sorry mate but its either the poor sound quality or your not fully understanding the true meaning of this piece. Dont just play the notes, put some thought into where your at in the song and determine how it should be played
-
This is way too loud. You should watch your tempo more. You can play notes and all, but the beauty of this piece was missing. Music isn't about reading notes on a page, there is so much more too it.
-
That was amazing! :) I'm 14 and just starting this piece. How long did it take you to learn it? It takes me forever to learn a new song.
-
Not bad. I think you need to keep a more consistent tempo throughout the piece...
I take it does change tempo, but I think it's missing that solid pulse.
Cheers!
-
I'm sure you are well above comments like miyachiman55s' but just in case your playing is fantastic, keep up the good work!
-
You remind me so much of one of my pianist friends! :)
-
Great job!
-
As a fellow student of about the same age, I applaud for you ^.^
-
at 4.56 minutes, it s probably too fast and yet in a curious way your interpretation works for me. in a word, it is exciting. no one is going to characterize your performance as lugubrious or ponderous. bravo.



This comment has received too many negative votes show
argh the second theme is horrible intrpreted...
karazh 1 year ago
@karazh : Another wonderfully constructive comment from someone who has never posted any of their playing for the youtube crowd to attack.
dhfeld 1 year ago