Uploaded by 666JSchaffer666 on Oct 9, 2008
Iced Earth - Setian Massacre , With Matt Barlow on Vocals.
From The 'I Walk Among You' E.P.
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (666JSchaffer666)
Top Comments
-
Matt Barlow is so much better.
2 years ago 18
-
I always prefer Tim over Matt. I think both are excellent singers, but Tim sounds more evil than Matt on those high pitched howls that I love. Matt's voice is amazing too, but after while, I get tired of it. Still, the way he channels his emotion through the music is sublime.
2 years ago 11
Video Responses
All Comments (108)
-
"All that they've ever loved is dead"... even this song like right now. Barlow is very good at his own songs, Horror Show is there so you can confirm, but c'mon, this one is Ripper's like all the other FA songs.
I personally enjoy very much both of them, that's just my opinion.
-
Matt is good in the studio AND live. Tim used to be a good live singer, and I think he still is, but when he sung live with Iced Earth, he just didn't have it.
-
First off the man has a family, so I understand why he left, and two, when he left, the band and the fans respected his choice to leave. I have all the respect in the world for the reson why he left Iced Earth.
-
Ripper is a good vocalist. But Barlow IS Iced Earth. Atleast to me Ripper could never get close.
-
This song was made for Ripper. He sounds better than Barlow here. Easily. More power.
-
@demolitionwolf91 Barlow left Iced Earth to works as a Cop. I dont think its fair to call him a boy
-
@megapurify Barlow is a great frontman and showman as well. So both of these great voices made us Iced Earth fans proud!
-
They are two of my main influences and I can tell you from singer's standpoint, Ripper's style is more difficult and demanding. Oddly though at the end of this run live with Iced Earth you heard Barlow's voice fall off the deep end in a hurry. I think due to the stress of Ripper's range and high note power. However, as Stu said recently on facebook that Ripper as an unbelievable high mid range as well. In a nutshell Ripper wins in technique and Matt wins with his emotion. Both are BRILLIANT!
-
The vocal lines of this song is so amazing. Credits to the Ripper Owens.
-
@666JSchaffer666 no it´s true Ripper just was standing at the monitor box and sing on the same place all the show- this sucks""!!! Matt is running over the stage and involve the peoples to the show. And Live he is a monster, absolutely great entertainer and he sings the ballads with much more emotions. I think Ripper just scream in the same notes all the time. It didn´t fit Iced Earth
- 8:01Iced Earth - The Coming Curse (Ripper Version)by 666JSchaffer6669,383 views
- 4:32Iced Earth - Birth of The Wicked (Ripper Version)by 666JSchaffer6669,155 views
- 9:07Iced Earth - The Clouding (Matt Barlow)by 666JSchaffer66682,641 views
- 4:15Iced Earth - Birth Of The Wicked (Matt + Tim D...by 666JSchaffer66612,917 views
- 6:59Iced Earth-I Walk Aloneby metalbeaner0996,828 views
- 9:30Iced Earth - Travel In Stygian (Days of Purgato...by Tormentor44432,352 views
- 4:30Iced Earth - Matt + Tim Duet (A Charge To Keep)by 666JSchaffer6665,647 views
- 6:23Invasion (Motivation Of Man)by Heavydarkrules12,139 views
- 4:22Iced Earth - A Charge To Keep with Matthew Barl...by Acidust9,777 views
- 4:18Iced Earth - A Charge To Keep (Matt Barlow)by 666JSchaffer66628,112 views
- 4:27Iced Earth - A Charge to Keep Barlow & Ripper ...by RaphKittyKat14,186 views
- 6:20Iced Earth-The Prophecyby metalbeaner0958,936 views
- 5:31Motivation of Man/Setian Massacre - Iced Earth ...by FritzIsMetal5,370 views
- 5:26Iced Earth - Behold The Wicked Childby SetAbominaesPower44,600 views
- 4:19Ten Thousand Strong - Iced Earth - Live 2008 Ph...by FritzIsMetal34,874 views
- 3:57Iced Earth God of Thunderby BlackSabotage100161,070 views
- 5:59Iced Earth - Enter the Realm + Colorsby gusstavoh18,381 views
- 3:41Iced Earth - Framing Armageddonby Soadevafan93321268,052 views
- 6:01Iced Earth - Prophecy (Ripper Version)by 666JSchaffer66620,658 views
- 5:53Iced Earth - Draculaby iktisat4tube2,190,308 views
its stupid to discuss whos better vocal i mean Ripper helped the band stay alive through time your beloved Barlow abandondem and then peacefuly left once he decided to come back to band
ps i still think this song fits Owens more
demolitionwolf91 2 years ago 5
ah *peacefully got fired!
666JSchaffer666 2 years ago
No being fired would be like in Metallica dissing off Dave or Maidens kicked out Paul this was twosided he knew he couldnt stay forever and wanted a project of his own once the boy Barlow twisted his tail back and crawled to Shaffer.
demolitionwolf91 2 years ago
Actually Schaffer was going to fire Tim regardless if Barlow came back or not, in fact he planned it before he even spoke to Matt. I wouldn't say that Barlow "crawled" back to schaffer, he wanted Barlow back, and Barlow just simply agreed!, even if he declined he said he would have searched for another singer.
so yes Tim WAS fired! ... Schaffer said he didn't like his live performance or something... he said he "lacked stage presence" .
666JSchaffer666 2 years ago 2
Well i never saw Iced Earth live with Ripper so i wouldnt know XD seen him with Hail! was puting up a decent show
demolitionwolf91 2 years ago
i saw him with iced earth in '07, and he ruled!, so i don't understand why Schaffer said he lacked in performance. I think he probably just missed matt or something!
666JSchaffer666 2 years ago 3