Bachpan 1963 - Tere Hum O Sanam - Rafi + Suman Kalyanpur
Uploader Comments (lovehumanity)
Top Comments
-
WOW!she had very very sweet voice.
All Comments (102)
-
The fact is that Lata and Rafi stopped singing with each other from 1963 to 1967. They had a clash regarding the copyright of the songs. So the music directors had to use either Suman/ Asha/ Sharda for female voice or Kishore/ Talat/ Manna Dey/ Mahendra Kapoor for male voice. Otherwise there was no chance of Sardar Malik using Suman in his song.
-
Playback singing is not merely a question of voice but also of suitable expression concerning situation AND role - in which Lata is only equalled, if not surpassed by, Mohd Rafi..
Concerning Lata's behaviour,NO SMOKE WITHOUT FIRE! (no such complaints about Rafi, Saigal, Kishore who enjoyed similar status as Lata)
Lata was neither producer/music director/financier - so why couldn't the film industry have followed OP Nayyar's lead? WHY DID THEY HAVE TO LICK HER BOOTS??
-
I meant that " one should NOT be biased in favor of Lata".
-
Suman has sung a great song with Rafi. She is every bit as good as Lata and has a higher range. One should be biased in favor of Lata. Make them both sing the same song and then you can judge better. Her voice is very similar to Lata, so one cannot say that Lata had a unique voice. I don't believe that Lata was unfair to any body. It is the fault of the incompetent and tone deaf music composers who could not judge Suman independently and had to follow the crowd, which is hardly ever a proper ju
-
thanks for the moldiest songs , this was first time I heard this song .
-
Long live Shankar Jaikishan for composing this beauty ... hidden gem .
Thanks for posting this.
-
I don't have the facts about Lataji ruining other playback singer's careers, but, please do not compare Lataji to anyone.
Her superiority can never be matched. I mean its one thing fan commenting based on preferences and another by esteemed knowledgeable musicians.
-
Did it ever occured to you guys that others could not compete with Lataji? She is far superior than others, so don't blame her for being selfish.
-
Lata and her sisters also destroyed the career of Mubharak Begum.
-
I think Rafi and Suman Kalyanpur sang the songs in Sanjh aur Savera beautifully. Can someone upload the wonderful song Ajahun na aaye balama from this movie. Thanks.
Dear Dr Bukhari, you are perfectly right in all that you have written, but one point is extremely doubtful: till 1949, Lata was still not a force to reckon with, and it is extremely unlikely that she could have been in the slightest way responsible for Noorjahan's decision to opt for Pakistan. I am sure even Noorjahan herself can not have made such a claim.
sgtalageri 2 years ago 4
thanx for being here..yes u may be right but then thats why i've opened this discussion for logical debate here and anyone can give opinion in decent words..also i believe that there can never be any comparisons as everybody is unique in one way or another.
lovehumanity 2 years ago