The Windmills of Your Mind § Navigating the Labyrinth
Uploader Comments (jtatlarge)
Top Comments
-
Yes..like the lyrics to that song ...Never ending our Beginning..on an ever spinning wheel...I still would give it ***** Great Vocal expression extraordinary interpretation
by Vanilla Fudge
-
♥ Incredible!!! Masterpiece!!! ♥ ♫ ♫ ♫
Video Responses
All Comments (29)
-
cut my teeth on psychedelia with vanilla fudge, iron butterfly, electric music for the mind and body by cj and the fish.still love those artists today. wow!
-
I was watching a program discussing the concept of the multiverse where things could be very much like the reality we know with some differences. I hope there's one where VF became as big as LZ. After all, LZ was their warm up act back when. On a side note, one of my first impressions of Queen was "Led Zeppelin with vocals". It was just a couple days ago plus twenty years that Freddie left us. I'd be interested to know what other artists you consider crucial. Bet we have more in common.
-
@jtatlarge Continuing previous comment, I'm not criticizing. I couldn't imagine doing another take of THAT vocal! If they were burned out (this being their last album before breaking up) they might have said hell with it good enough but good enough from VF surpasses many other artists' finest moments. Shredding is great, but I like emotion in my music. Great video BTW.
-
THANK YOU
@jtatlarge Yes I mean VF's version. I never concerned myself with differences (changes, "errors"). I may have been dimly aware of the song and Michel LeGrand but this is it as far as I'm concerned. The "correct" structure of the song without the space at the end of each line sounds "wrong" to me. Mark is really pushing the limits of his voice here and he's a little flat in couple spots, most notably 4:49. And what is that feedback at 5:24? I wouldn't have expected that in the studio.
lovethatswivo 3 months ago
@lovethatswivo I don`think he`s flat unintentionally in this one. He was great at the angst-ridden vocal. At 4:49 its just the flatside of the slow vibrato (listen to Of Her Hair etc 6:20-6:45), as he slides upwards to the note. Also Just the Fingers of Your Hand 5:09-5:22. I love these four tunes. In some sense, they had it all over LedZepp (metal gods may now rain on me). Plant vs three guys with coherent harmonic voices, almost Wilsonesque. VF wins.
jtatlarge 3 months ago
hi jtatlarge. Isn't this Mark singing? Hearing other versions of this song was always a big letdown for me. I love love love it.
lovethatswivo 3 months ago
@lovethatswivo I'm not 100% sure, but I think so. However, apparently most of the lyrical changes in Windmills were Carmine's - I heard this from a Shadow Morton interview third-hand, so perhaps its not 100% solid. When I said version I meant VF version, not the singer per se.
jtatlarge 3 months ago
It's actually:
Pictures hanging in a hallway
And a fragment of this song
Half remembered names and faces
NOT
half forgotten!!!
activenight 4 months ago
@activenight Congratulations. You are the first to notice. I actually left several common errors and some of Carmine's "changes" (you noted 2). Whirling. Carmine's version changes some lyrics for dramatic effect. "You were suddenly aware" rather than "Were you suddenly aware", and "jingle" twice vs jingle / jangle. Plus a few others. I particularly liked Carmine's "Where's that jingle in your head". Given the meter, I think it fits.
jtatlarge 4 months ago