If there is a God perhaps, like in the movie "Oh God", God doesn't know how to make an up without a down, an inside without an outside, joy without pain. It seems to me that that is about the best explaination I have ever heard. Of course, there really is no God and road kill and infants with cancer is simply part of the natural world.
The believers affair is a unique and strange one, if God gives him something good he is grateful and that is good for him, if God tries him he is patient and that is good for him to. May Allah guide this man to Islam
@hpyrkh3 I think most people are misunderstanding what he is saying. He is saying that when God puts us under trials there is a wisdom behind it, even behind the pain and we not wanting the pain. Even if we, the slaves of God don't know the reason behind the pain, ther eis a wisdom behind it but patience is key.
If we dont understand suffering, then it's pointless. It's only like kicking a dog that doesnt understand what it did to deserve being kicked. However, if we could understand WHY we got this suffering, what we DID do to deserve it, we could actually LEARN something from it specifically and grow from it. Yes, we can still grow from it but in a much more difficult way, most of the time directionless trying to grasp at any reason it might be happening but we dont know. Really ridiculous and cruel.
@naavaleh He is saying that he doesn't understand why there is suffering in the world, but he believes that God does. He doesn't explain why there is suffering in the world.
is there not a contradiction here? the first 2 minutes of this video explain why there is suffering in this world, and the last 17 seconds say that we cannot understand suffering. this is something that's always driven me nuts when i hear things like this. what am i missing?
...and that ultimately the good and the bad of this world is a token of God's mercy because the believer receives for both much more in return if he can respond to it by moving closer to God, like the child who clings onto mum :)
If there is a God perhaps, like in the movie "Oh God", God doesn't know how to make an up without a down, an inside without an outside, joy without pain. It seems to me that that is about the best explaination I have ever heard. Of course, there really is no God and road kill and infants with cancer is simply part of the natural world.
rustytool100 3 months ago
@FATAL12SKILLZ He is talking about G-d not your misguided perception of Him,
AbuAvital 3 months ago
The believers affair is a unique and strange one, if God gives him something good he is grateful and that is good for him, if God tries him he is patient and that is good for him to. May Allah guide this man to Islam
FATAL12SKILLZ 5 months ago
@hpyrkh3 I think most people are misunderstanding what he is saying. He is saying that when God puts us under trials there is a wisdom behind it, even behind the pain and we not wanting the pain. Even if we, the slaves of God don't know the reason behind the pain, ther eis a wisdom behind it but patience is key.
FATAL12SKILLZ 5 months ago
Pure wisdom, thank you Rabbi
2000Betelgeuse 9 months ago 2
If we dont understand suffering, then it's pointless. It's only like kicking a dog that doesnt understand what it did to deserve being kicked. However, if we could understand WHY we got this suffering, what we DID do to deserve it, we could actually LEARN something from it specifically and grow from it. Yes, we can still grow from it but in a much more difficult way, most of the time directionless trying to grasp at any reason it might be happening but we dont know. Really ridiculous and cruel.
SarahRachel59 10 months ago
@naavaleh He is saying that he doesn't understand why there is suffering in the world, but he believes that God does. He doesn't explain why there is suffering in the world.
hpyrkh3 11 months ago
is there not a contradiction here? the first 2 minutes of this video explain why there is suffering in this world, and the last 17 seconds say that we cannot understand suffering. this is something that's always driven me nuts when i hear things like this. what am i missing?
naavaleh 1 year ago
If I could choose between this Rabbi or Brad Pitt to be my husbabd I choose the Rabbi !
arual1969 1 year ago
...and that ultimately the good and the bad of this world is a token of God's mercy because the believer receives for both much more in return if he can respond to it by moving closer to God, like the child who clings onto mum :)
shafichy 1 year ago