Warning Muslims from Hizb ut-Tahrir and Their Ugly Beliefs

The leader of Hizb at-Tahrir, Taqiyyud-Din an-Nabahaniyy, said in his book, Ash-Shakhsiyyah al-Islamiyyah (Volume 1, pages 71-72): "These actions (i.e., the actions of man) are not related to Allahs creating and Allahs creating is not related to them, because man is the one who performs them by his will and choice, thereupon, the voluntary actions do not fall under Allahs creating."

He also said in the same book (Volume 2, page 74): "Rendering the reward or punishment contingent upon guidance and misguidance denotes guidance and misguidance are doings of the slave and not from Allah." He stated a similar thing on page 72 in another one of his books called Nidham-ul-Islam.

Nabahaniyys Negation of the Quran

Allah ta^ala said in Surat-ul-Furqan, Ayah 2:which means: [He created everything and made terms for them.]
Allah said in Surat As-Saffat, Ayah 96: which means: [Allah created you and your doings.]

Allah said in Surat al-Qamar, Ayah 49:which means: [Verily, I have created everything according to My Destiny.]

So, if Hizb at-Tahrirs claim was correct i.e., every voluntary action of the slave is a creation of the slave himself, then what the slaves would create among their actions would be more than what Allah creates--a thought the sound intellect totally rejects. Linguistically, the term shay (thing) refers to what is existing--which includes these voluntary actions.

Also, Allah said in Surat al-A^raf, Ayah 155: which means: [You misguide with it whomever You will, and guide whomever You will.] This Ayah stands as explicit evidence that Allah is the One Who creates the guidance in the hearts of those whom He willed to guide, and the misguidance in the hearts of those whom He willed to misguide.

Hence, it is irrefutable that an-Nabahaniyy negates the Quran. Likewise, the statements of their leader contradict all other similar meanings that are in the Book of Allah. These meanings include: Allah is the One Who gives the belief out of His Benevolence and Generosity to whomever He wills among His slaves; Allah is the One Who makes the belief beloved to the heart of the slave, decorates it in his heart, and guides him to the straight path; Allah seals the hearts of some of His slaves; no one can do what is not written for him, and the slave does not harm or benefit himself or others except if Allah willed; all the doings of the slaves happen by the Will of Allah, and there is no saying, doing, or intention of a human which would take place except by the Will of Allah, ta^ala.

An-Nabahaniyys Negation of the Hadith

As related by Ibn Hibban, the Prophet said: which means: "Allah is the Creator of every doer and his doing."

Also, the Prophet, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, said: which means: "Those who claim there is no Destiny (Qadar) (i.e., they claim that the slave creates his doings) are the zoroastians (majus) of this nation. If they get sick, do not visit them, and if they die, do not attend their funeral." This was related by Abu Dawud in his Sunan and al-Bayhaqiyy in his book, Al-Qadar.

Moreover, an-Nabahaniyy negated the hadith that was related and determined to be sahih by Ibn Jarir at-Tabariyy in his book, Tahdhib ul-Athar: which means: "Two types among my nation have no share in Islam, those who deny Destiny (al-Qada) and al-Murjiah" This hadith is explicit in classifying as blasphemous those who deny Qadar. Hence, Hizb at-Tahrir, by saying: "The slave creates his own actions by his will and creating," have deprived themselves of Islam and separated themselves from it like the snake sloughs off its skin

http://www.alsunna.org

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Hizb
• ut
• at
• Tahrir
• Tahreer
• Tuhrir
• Ikwan
• Warning
• Terrorists
• Islamic
• Army
• Jihad
• Mujahidun
• Shaheed
• Martyr
• Muslim
• Bosnia

[mjazzguitar]

So why send someone to hell for something he is not responsible for?

[Brotherofheart]

@mjazzguitar

Firsty i would like to quote Surat As-Saffat, Ayah 96 Allah said (which means) "Allah created you and your doings"

Allah knew and Willed Eternally that some of His slaves will be misguided. Allah does as He Wills, He owns us and we do not object to Him, He is just in whatever he Willed to be.

We are responsible for our actions because we have a will. Our will falls under the Will of Allah. If we will to do something that Allah Eternally never Willed to be, it shall not be

[Historicalia]

Nabhani also says in Shaksiyyah Volume 1:

'there is clear indication that the one who does the guiding and misguiding is Allah (SWT) and not the servant. This means the servant does not find guidance by himself, rather he is guided when Allah (SWT) guides him. When Allah (SWT) sends him astray he goes astray.'

I think you may have accidentally misqouted him. May Allah prevent us from any wrong doing. Ameen.

[Brotherofheart]

@Historicalia

He contradicts himself many times in the same book and on different subjects. In the same volume on page 71 & 72 he says: "These actions (i.e., the actions of man) are not related to Allahs creating and Allahs creating is not related to them, because man is the one who performs them by his will and choice, thereupon, the voluntary actions do not fall under Allahs creating."

Its not a misqoute even his followers agree to this belief.

[7aniba3al]

but what we realy need at this moment is for a khilapha to come, as it is the first 3orwa that has been destroyed it must come back first.so do you have a solution?

This is what the ummah needs.

[Brotherofheart]

@7aniba3al

Yes we do need one but that doesnt mean to support this fanatic and misguided group. The only time we will get a caliph is when imam al-Mahdi is brought forth as there are too much sects declaring eevryone as kuffar and the wahhabis are also spreading their fitnah rapidly

[mindoasis11]

HT and similar groups are funded by Saudi Arabia and are akin to the Khawarij.

They are hypocrites, and we'll use force murder brutality in the name of Allah(swt).

They brand others kaffir and kufr when they themselves are Kaffir and kufr.

They commit shirk by acting as Allah(swt), making judgments and doing deeds and calling them his deeds.

Like imperialists and fascists they need to be dealt harshly.

We muslim communists are ready but are u?

Ramadan Mubarak

God bless Communism

[drbilalphilips]

Hizb ut tahrir are a very deviant group.

[Brotherofheart]

Imam an-Nasafiyy in his Aqeedah said if a man threw a stone at a glass, then this act of throwing and breaking are by the Creation of Allah and not the slave, the slave would only have acquired this act and NOT THE CREATING OF IT!

Because Allah is the Creator of this man, his intention, his hand, his movement, the throwing and the breaking.

[Brotherofheart]

The belief you have is the same as the Qadariyyah (those who deny al-Qadr). Ibn Asakir in Tareekh Dimashq in the 48th volume narrated that Imam Al-Awzaiyy debated with a Qadariyyah defeated him and declared him as a kaffir to the Caliph at the time. The Caliph chopped his head, arms and legs and hung him on the border of Dimashq for all to see and to warn others of them.

May Allah protect us from such beleifs. Allah is the Creator of everything!!