Pérotin: Viderunt omnes [with score - original manuscript]
Uploader Comments (flammesombres)
Top Comments
-
Does anybody else find this music beautiful?
All Comments (68)
-
Only one thing I can say...This composition doesn't date 1198. Almost all historians agree that Perotinus Magnus earliest works began 1208. I think OP is thinking of Leoninus work by the same name.
-
I am the number 59.000 who watch this video :)
-
@pawn62 Homoerotic?
-
@12dl196 no
-
@flammesombres It's a good scholarly book. It is indeed true that Perotin's contemporaries viewed the new Notre Dame polyphony with hostility and some certainly did go to the extremes of describing it as effeminate and homoerotic. It's hard for us in the 21st century to believe this music could be controversial but church music before this was much simpler.
-
@pawn62 effeminizing and homoerotic music? Nonsense :)
-
@flammesombres Quite a while indeed! Although, It is surprising to most how much in common the notation of chant, and our modern notation have!
-
@pawn62 thats why i can never get into many musical analysis books about composers, even tho i want to. too much pretentious academic bullshit, not enough substantive theory about the music itself. that's what i've noticed anyway.
-
My jaw dropped when I saw the year 1198. Thank goodness for written music. We're able to reproduce this millennium-old piece and experience something like what people commonly listened to so long ago. It's surreal when pondering it; though, I find that curious in itself. I do not feel such when considering visual works from the Middle Ages or any other time. Perhaps music is different because verbal communication from long ago is so much rarer, less likely to have been preserved.
I'm slogging my way through "Music, Body, and Desire in Medieval Culture" by Bruce Holsinger (Stanford U. Press). He cites contemporary opinion that this Notre Dame polyphony is essentially effeminizing and homoerotic. Happy listening!
pawn62 5 months ago
@pawn62 Thanks for the heads-up. I'll be sure to steer clear of that book...
flammesombres 5 months ago 17