Miss Saigon with Lyrics - 20 - I'd Give My Life For You
Top Comments
All Comments (44)
-
I like Joanna's version more.
-
@rikkulockhart15 Righto. Rock on sweetheart.
*thumbs up*
-
@Maranedy To each their own. Both versions are good in their own ways.
Lea Salonga's has great emotion to it and was recorded when she was in her teens (in fact it was the role that made her famous.)
Joanna Ampil's version has a stronger vibrato to it.
-
@sugarhoneyicedtea123 Honestly, I like both Lea Salonga AND Joanna Ampil. I don't judge either singer. They both did good jobs in my opinion and here's why:
1. Lea Salonga originated the role and started playing it at 17 years old (London) and 19 (Broadway.) Lea Salonga tends to do better with emotion in her roles.
2. Joanna Ampil played the role from 1993-1995 and is a few years younger than Lea Salonga. In my opinion, she has better vibrato.
-
@TheJimjamgemma as am I, good luck! :)
-
This song is beautiful
-
The two minutes of this sing give me chills.
-
love this recording, love lea aswell, this one is easier to sing to as most the ones of lea on youtube are live so have clapping and wooing
I like Lea's version more....
Maranedy 1 year ago 39
I feel like everyone just like's Lea's version better because she's famous. I love Lea too but I'm not a huge fan of her rendition of this song. I think Joanna's voice is bigger and has more intensity than Lea's does in this song.
sugarhoneyicedtea123 5 months ago 9