Hana Makhmalbaf: "Buda az sharm foru rikht" (2)

After the screening of her film "Buddha Collapsed Out of Shame" Hana Makhmalbaf responded to the questions of the audience of the Berlin Film Festival 2008. Second part.

In Farsi with English subtitles. Added pictures have been taken from the website www.makhmalbaf.com, the added music is the beginning of the song "Bade Saba", by Sussan Deyhim.

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• Hana
• Makhmalbaf
• Iranian
• Cinema
• Bamiyan
• Bamian
• Bamyan
• Afghanistan
• Sussan
• Deyhim

[Matveich1002]

Honnestly, when you see some of the questions being asked to Makhmalbaf were pretty obvious, almost insulting. You could see her loosing patience. Have they not eyes to see, ears to hear, hearts to understand? I guess Buda az sharm foru rikht's beautiful yet deep and tragic simplicity is too much for a certain audience.

Good job, Hana.

[deuxfleuves]

@Matveich1002 this film was included in the children's section of the festival, so that explains the nature of some of the questions. The audience was mainly composed by children.

[MISSJINOOS]

IN LAHJE MASGHARE CHIE ?????

[deuxfleuves]

Don't know what you mean, and I guess the majority of youtube users doesn't know that either. Please translate that into English or French.

[zad73]

From what I've leaned is that "Hana Makhmalbaf" was born and raised in Iran, and has lives there all her life... so whey does she have a deep western ascent???

[deneilg]

even a Buddha stone that can't even move was not allowed to be there how about all those human living thing that can turn in front of them everyday without being suffer?

[Matveich1002]

@deuxfleuves ahh my bad, had no idea! It changes the perspective then, thanks for shedding the light;)

[mochalef]

@roshanfekr Be khatere in ke inha khodeshan ra kheyli "philsouf" midanad, dar surati ke ghadre khar halishan nist :(( hala inha ra ham mikhahand be onwane yek bote bozorg be Iraniha tahmil konand:(( aman az an rouzi ke be tanabe inha kassi berawad bar chah :((((

[berkeh15]

chera dokhtarhaye makhmalbaf hame jendeand,tof be koset

[tshapour]

Zendebad Makhmalbaf ,as bozorg ta kochakeshan

[amir4barca]

your accent is friggin annoying kiddo! we don't use "wow" in our conversations you little spoiled brat!

[star74d]

cheghadr Vool vool mikhore , hanoz hichi nashodeh khodesho kheyli gom kardeh fekr kardeh POKHY HAST...

[star74d]

Bayad posht pardeh ra did ?????????

[star74d]

Na aziz joon masaleh in nist ke asl dastan farmosh besheh. Maslaeh inke hanoz hichi nashodeh aval kar khodeshon ra gom kardann ,, Taze fekr mikone ke ostad in kar hast ke dare be hame yad mid ba che didi hata film ra bebinad... hal ham bad az Khizesh meli mardom khodeshon ra khanevadegi sokhangoy mardom mibinand va be naam mardom IRANharf mizaned. betore sadetar begam har ja ke barashon polsaztar bashe ...onja hastand chon taghziyeh mishan az taraf gardan kolofta.. khob be nafeshon hast..