Logical Song by Roger Hodgson who actually wrote it OR Supertramp without Roger (Hodgson)

Here is The Logical Song written & composed by Roger Hodgson performed by Roger with Orchestra and then Supertramp with Orchestra playing Roger's song.

Which do you prefer? Roger playing his songs OR Supertramp playing Roger's songs - You choose.

I have to say Roger's Orchestra shows are my favorites and his musicianship is amazing whether he is solo, with a band or an orchestra. Roger's performances have so much heart, energy, feeling and expression. In comparison Supertramp sounds so flat and mechanical.

Does anyone else have any videos of Supertramp the last 27 years. They are hard to find on YouTube and I'd really appreciate if you'd send them to me so I can do more videos.

Please post comments on my channel and/or the videos. Love to hear from everyone.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• The
• Logical
• Song
• Orchestra
• Roger
• Hodgson
• Supertramp
• Rick
• Davis
• John
• Helliwell
• 70-10
• Tour
• Greatest
• Hits
• 40th
• anniversary
• concerts
• festivals
• bands
• live
• music

[amerikanprincess]

The footage is wonderful on the Roger & Orchestra and he's happy and involved like he always is at a great show... and the singer/keyboardist on the Supertramp video and everyone else involved is grim. distant and doing a job. No comparison... (If there's anything I can't stand it's when musicians act like they're doing a JOB... what the hell is the audience coming to FORGET... that they have JOBS!!)

[RationalDischarge]

There's definitely no contest. Hodgson radiates far more love for the music and joy of performing than does his "replacement", if I may use that word very loosely. That's the mark of a real entertainer. I haven't even been into Supertramp that long so it's not as if I'm a fanboy or anything, but it doesn't take a fanboy to tell that one performer knows how to breathe life into every note while the other is just giving a rushed, rote performance of a song he doesn't really "feel" anything for.

[tarponnut]

No comparison.

[martin3064]

Great songwriter !! Love he's music

[j79041]

Roger Hodgson worte the lyrics, knows what is being said and what he wants to say to the listener, while the singer/keyboardist for Supertramp without Roger is just singing the song. Its like and artist who painted the pricture and then the artist reproducing the picture for sale.

Love several of the music written by Roger and his messages in them.

[909duk]

Was never much into Supertramp, but sure is a difference between singers. Never changed stations on this song. Does bring back memories.

[Dommus50]

great Roger!

[ziaolol]

@amerikanprincess very well said, it anoys me to no end when a musician isnt showing passion.