TheAtheistAntidote Vs ??? part2

The second of a 2 part answer to who I would like to see TheAtheistAntidote debate. I eliminate popular atheists (many whom I call friends) one by one until I reach my ultimate answer. I try to give good honest reasoning for each one that I do not choose and ultimately for the one that I do.
I pray for TAA in this endeavour as these debates never really solve anything, but they do give people plenty of reason to ridicule you. I know TAA has some thick skin... I hope he's wearing body armour as well.
My thanks to all those watching and I hope that there are no hard feelings if you are one of the ones I did not pick.

Links to folks I mentioned (check them all out you won't be disappointed):
Funsizedchoco:
http://www.youtube.com/user/funsizedchoco
Repzion:
http://www.youtube.com/user/repzion
Kennythesage:
http://www.youtube.com/user/KennyTheSage
antybu86:
http://www.youtube.com/user/antybu86
ThoughtfulAtheist:
http://www.youtube.com/user/ThoughtfulAtheist
Freethinker3161:
http://www.youtube.com/user/FreeThinker3161
InModiasWeTrust:
http://www.youtube.com/user/InModiasWeTrust
bewarethelizards42:
http://www.youtube.com/user/bewarethelizards42
MarklRoss2:
http://www.youtube.com/user/marklross2
CapnnOrdinary:
http://www.youtube.com/user/CapnnOrdinary
Coughllin666:
http://www.youtube.com/user/Coughlin666
DavidJohnWellman:
http://www.youtube.com/user/DavidJohnWellman

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• TheAtheistAntidote
• Funsizedchoco
• ThoughtfulAtheist
• Freethinker3161
• InModiasWeTrust
• bewarethelizards42
• Marklross2
• Capnnordinary
• Antybu86
• Repzion
• Kennythesage
• Coughlin666
• DavidJOhnWellman
• Christianity
• debate
• vote

[Wyglyph]

And you think Brock is DJW's intellectual equal? You're a nice guy, my friend, but I fear your powers of discrimination require some tweaking.

[thereprieve]

The fundamental difference between DJW and TAA is that DJW has a degree in strawmanning =)

DJW actually told me that we cannot prove the earth's roundness... philosophically. I guess that's how you avoid losing an argument... you obscure the facts. So if I have to choose sides, I side with my brother in Christ. Even if I were an atheist, I would do my best to discern which guy cares about other people more. And it has yet to appear to be DJW.

[thereprieve]

So it seems that I am being proven right in my choice for the debate. As many people seem to dislike DJW as you dislike Brock. I guess if he picks DJW... we get to find out for sure.

[Wyglyph]

DJW makes you mad, but Brock doesn't? DJW is responding directly to Brock's generalizations, insults, strawman arguments and plagiarism. Can you tell me how DJW compares to that?

[thereprieve]

TAA makes you mad and DJW doesn't? Wellman strawman's Christianity in almost every video when he's not picking on TAA. He outright slanders Brock... something I highly doubt he would do in person. Brock plagiarized and apologized and has since corrected himself. There's not much I can do if you do not think the apology was sincere. I take him at his word, as I would DJW if he apologized for strawmanning Christianity.

[lifeisfair123]

I would much rather you debate any of these people instead of Brock. You are the more intelligent and are a real thinker about everything.

[thereprieve]

I appreciate the compliment. You know what??? What the heck... bring it on!!! I'm up for a good debate. =)

[thisguysajerk]

you couldn't debate your way out of a paper bag....

you might get angry and punch your way out...lol

mr. angry pants.

[RobotzAreAwesome]

David is a great choice, but what's with the backhanded compliment? David is "probably his intelectual equal". Brock is a confirmed plagerist with dozens of factual errors in his videos just in the past couple weeks.

[InModiasWeTrust]

Jay, regardless of your respect for TAA, the vast majority (myself included) of us have a much greater level of respect for you than we do for Brock. You are the Batman to his Alfred if anything, certainly not the other way around. If you are still up for our discussion which may or may not lead to a debate, I would like to start that around September 1st. I think we have a lot in common and a lot of differences, making for a long and interesting talk. Let's both start considering topics...