Norman Finkelstein vs Shlomo Ben Ami - Part 4
Loading...
Uploaded by mingoi313 on Mar 1, 2007
In Part Four of the discussion, Shlomo Ben Ami discusses the unsustainable political context within Israel that lead to their withdrawal from the Taba talks. Professor Norman Finkelstein goes on to address the question of Anti-Semitism in the US and the role that this factor plays in distorting the case for Palestine.
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (147)
-
@hometv1970 Lol, Clinton blaming others again
-
Ben-Ami was foreign minister, so I think he wanted to be careful with his words so he's not labeled as a traitor (see Goldstone). He's a good scholar from what I have read - Israelis usually are not so dishonest when you read their scholarly work. See Benny Morris, good historian, but he has extreme contempt for Arabs/Palestinians and is very dishonest in his commentaries. Interesting debate though
-
Excellent debate. First time I've seen an Israeli spokesperson who hasn't interrupted, diverted the issue or resorted to propagandist outbursts with Norman.
-
So your brilliant position is that two wrongs make a right? Because the U.S. committed crimes against humanity, it is okay for Israel to do so? The stupidity of that line of "reasoning" should be obvious.
-
Finkelstein and Vanunu are the bravest jews alive, and the most honest
-
i just want to say to all the zionists and israelese "fuck you"
-
these bastards just need another good kicking! make this bastards humble again!
-
Bill Clinton My Life (Vintage Books 2005) pg 946
"Arafat had said he accepted the parameters with reservations. The problem was that his reservations, unlike Israel’s, were outside the parameters"
-
anti-semite= in opposition to 3% running the world.
-
It's not a debate, they both essentially agree with Ami acting the part of the apologist. Wow.
9:35Norman Finkelstein vs Shlomo Ben Ami - Part 5by mingoi31328,824 views
- 10:00Norman Finkelstein vs Shlomo Ben Ami - Part 3by mingoi31345,348 views
- 9:58Debate Panel on Israel: Norman Finkelstein & Wo...by mingoi31314,784 views
- 9:49Norman Finkelstein vs Shlomo Ben Ami - Part 1by mingoi313120,747 views
- 10:12Norman Finkelstein vs Martin Indyk over Gaza an...by mediagrrl944,395 views
- 8:29Debate Panel on Israel: Norman Finkelstein & Wo...by mingoi3139,934 views
- 9:52DN! Norman Finkelstein on AIPAC (1)by StartLoving318,782 views
- 9:29Norman Finkelstein vs Martin Indyk over Gaza an...by mediagrrl920,001 views
- 10:43Norman Finkelstein - Is Jimmy Carter Anti-Semit...by concernedbrandeis33,053 views
- 5:38The Holocaust Industry # 6by irregularissue15,416 views
- 57:39Is Criticism of Israel Anti-Semitic? Part 1by bussdriver21,851 views
- 3:51Chomsky on Dershowitz' "jihad" against Finkelst...by americanhummus43,025 views
- 9:58Finkelstein versus Dershowitz debate, part 2 of 11by Valelacerte51,368 views
- 6:39Norman Finkelstein answering question about Cho...by dw304133,767 views
- 10:45A BIG debate on Israel/Palestine Nakba-1/4by IWantDemocracyNow15,883 views
- 9:58Finkelstein versus Dershowitz debate, part 5 of 11by Valelacerte37,017 views
- 9:14The Holocaust Industry #2by irregularissue25,607 views
- 6:46Norman Finkelstein Banned From Israel Talks Abo...by rattansifan16,110 views
- 9:02Finkelstein on Gaza Massacreby VideoNewsService13,447 views
- 4:05Finkelstein - Bruce Leeby byakoonin67,064 views
Norman is brilliant!!!!
NYCHustler03 2 years ago 102
Thumbs up for Mr Finkelstein but also for Mr Ben Ami , he was a polite gentleman which defended his arguments in a reasonable-objective-non-sensationalist way.
Bautisnemo 2 years ago 67