@yusufulhas anybody can create stories about khidir... but how can we be sure? tha fact is... if khidir is alive, he should have bai'at the prophet as the sahaba had done. & he should have helped the prophet when the people of Taif pelted him with stones and when the musyrikeen broke his tooth at Uhud. Where is your Khidir during the Battle of Badar, when 300+ Muslims had to face thousands of Musyrikeen? When the prophet cried under the tree at night and asked Allaah for help?
i'm only reminding to myself, do have patience and never claim ourselves the most knowledgable in deen, take heed from the story of musa (as) and khidir (as), insyaAllah.
either sufi or salafi, or any other sect, we all hold a small portion of truth in our believes until we announced more knowledgable, and speaking that we know not, and then is when we leave from the ilham and protection of Allah.
anyway, eid mubarak brothers, and sorry for any mistakes i made.
@yusufulhas and @ibnusardi masyaAllah, may Allah have mercy on both of my brothers. there's never a doubt in practising dzikr in islam whether loud or isolated, so please don't condemn one of the best ibadah for soul purification. do be honest, and check with the quran and hadith.
brother yusufulhas had already denounced any form of wahdatul wujud and bidaat, so have patience with his ibadah and opinion. on the other hand, bro yusufulhas, dont call others kufr or it might come back to you.
have u heard the hadith about dhul kurwaisa? a man came up to the prophet(saw)(from najd) and told him fear Allah. umar(ra) requested that he cut off his head. He is the most prominent from the "salaf us salih"
zikr fasting salah all of these things are mystical. your claim that islam is not mystical only shows foolishness and lack of knowledge. only mystics fast
stop with your logic. logic isn't factual
yusufulhas 3 months ago
@ibnusardi
did u not know that khidr attended rasulullah(saw)'s funeral?
yusufulhas 3 months ago
@yusufulhas anybody can create stories about khidir... but how can we be sure? tha fact is... if khidir is alive, he should have bai'at the prophet as the sahaba had done. & he should have helped the prophet when the people of Taif pelted him with stones and when the musyrikeen broke his tooth at Uhud. Where is your Khidir during the Battle of Badar, when 300+ Muslims had to face thousands of Musyrikeen? When the prophet cried under the tree at night and asked Allaah for help?
ibnusardi 3 months ago
:)
ibnuhussin83 3 months ago
i'm only reminding to myself, do have patience and never claim ourselves the most knowledgable in deen, take heed from the story of musa (as) and khidir (as), insyaAllah.
either sufi or salafi, or any other sect, we all hold a small portion of truth in our believes until we announced more knowledgable, and speaking that we know not, and then is when we leave from the ilham and protection of Allah.
anyway, eid mubarak brothers, and sorry for any mistakes i made.
wassalam.
janganketawa 3 months ago
and btw i'm not into loud zikr. i'm just arguing with him because he's opposing the truth.
yusufulhas 3 months ago
@janganketawa
jazakallahu khair brother.
yusufulhas 3 months ago
@yusufulhas and @ibnusardi masyaAllah, may Allah have mercy on both of my brothers. there's never a doubt in practising dzikr in islam whether loud or isolated, so please don't condemn one of the best ibadah for soul purification. do be honest, and check with the quran and hadith.
brother yusufulhas had already denounced any form of wahdatul wujud and bidaat, so have patience with his ibadah and opinion. on the other hand, bro yusufulhas, dont call others kufr or it might come back to you.
janganketawa 3 months ago
@ibnusardi
have u heard the hadith about dhul kurwaisa? a man came up to the prophet(saw)(from najd) and told him fear Allah. umar(ra) requested that he cut off his head. He is the most prominent from the "salaf us salih"
yusufulhas 3 months ago
@ibnusardi
zikr fasting salah all of these things are mystical. your claim that islam is not mystical only shows foolishness and lack of knowledge. only mystics fast
yusufulhas 3 months ago