JEWISH MORNING BLESSINGS
Uploader Comments (omedyashar)
Top Comments
-
maybe in my ignorance i'm misunderstanding the term, but it was my understanding that 'minhag' means something along the lines of a tradition, which you're supposed to follow ASSUMING it's in accordance with halakha.
Also from my understanding, there are talmudic laws requiring correct pronunciation during prayer, so this would override one's father's pronunciation.
-
if u know hebrew its easy to learn (harder for askenazim )
Video Responses
All Comments (50)
-
THAT WAS BEAUTIFUL
-
@nasifnahle Yes this is not unusual at all and not just older books.It's the "scientific transliteration" which isn't necessarily following pronunciation eg dh is just soft d, which for those that pronounce it soft,is THe. But they write dh.Like b, bh. bh is pronounced. Any modern academic book has it tooo.How come that book you mention isnt even mentioned on Google?On second look, is this it? Ramírez, A., Nociones de Gramática Hebrea y crestomatía bíblica, Bilbao 1924 So is it not in English?
-
@bolius1... By Ignacio Ramirez. Hebrew Grammar. 1924. And yes, it says Waw for Vav. Vav is not mentioned in the book. For example, instead David, it says Dowidh.
-
@nasifnahle Great. By who? I know the more academic books use that. w/waw for vav e.t.c.
-
and by the way, i'm not saying one is superior to another. such a general statement would be false. Listen to a british person say Bob(kamatz) It's not like you americans do it, like a nanny goat. bahhhhhhh b. British say Off, Orange, Bob, it's with a KAMATZ o. ashkenazi kamatz = yemenite kamatz. American english doesn't have the sound. This is a fault with the american pronunciation being applied to hebrew. Ashkenazi pronunciation is spot on for that.
curious, are these bera7ot actually using ashkenazi vowel pronunciations with a mizrahi consonant syste? e.g. "ato adonai"?
ceniboy 10 months ago
@ceniboy
Yemenite vowel pronunciation. Ashkenazim aren't the only 'eida that distinguishes between qamaS and pataH.
Berakhoth is with a khaf (5), not a Hheth (7).
All the best :)
omedyashar 10 months ago