true HD Haley Reinhart "The House of the Rising Sun" Top 5 American Idol 2011 (May 4)
Top Comments
All Comments (394)
-
I hope to meet her one day and sing for her. She has the most amazing voice and performer!
-
Not only is she STUNNINGLY beautiful, but she has the most amazing voice I have ever heard. How she didn't win I will never understand. Haley's voice cuts straight to your soul and its amazing!!!!!
-
SHE SHOULD'VE WON! NOT SCOTTY!
-
@megbarnes44 Really? Doubt it he will be around all that long to prove your factoid!
-
No one else ever interpreted this song this way and I didn't like the original version, but this was pure magic, best performance of 2011. Sheryl was right, Steven was right, J-Lo was right and Randy was right. Amazingly done, couldn't have been better.
-
It's driving me mad that people are coming here saying this pip guy is better
This is Haley's very unique arrangement
It's so very different than it had ever been done before then
It was her idea to start slow and build up the song, put a bluesy feel to it and so on...
Then this pip guy comes along and sings it EXACTLY the same way
So how can he be better??
Like seriously WTF
-
Pip is better
-
This is one of the few Idol performances I've ever heard that actually left me speechless. All I could come up with is 'holy shit!'. Her rendition of Benny and the Jets was fantastic, and (I feel) much better than Sir Elton's, but this song blew me away.
-
@enterthekraken I've never heard a version like hers before. And it's irrelevant if someone has done it before, Haley did an excellent job.
-
@enterthekraken I guess after you listen to the muppets there ain't anything that could sound good.
this is pretty much the best idol performance ever.
Jsadella 1 month ago 77
@SeetherRocks100
Don't sell yourself short. You like James Durbin. You can take anything.
LookingAtYouFool 2 months ago in playlist Haley Reinhart HD 44