Renee Fleming - Elijah (Mendelssohn) - Hear Ye, Israel
Uploader Comments (PukKoleszka)
Top Comments
-
I don't think it's that bad. I rather like her. My favorite rendition though is Eleanor Steber.
-
I agree with Dymension. My favorite recording of this is Eleanor Steber.
Video Responses
All Comments (31)
-
Lovely performance. Not sure why the grousing about diction. The aria is terribly high so many sopranos will opt for lyricism over diction. Fleming is superior to Rosalinde Plowright in this regard. My personal favorite on recordings is Gwyneth Jones on the EMI Fruehbeck de Burgos recording. She has ample power, diction, lyricism and heart. One of her rare outstanding recordings.
-
She has a lovely voice, and you can hear every word.
-
Not her best performance. Her diction is not terribly good. But I love listening to Renee Fleming, and I think her critics can be vicious.
-
@gharusa Clearly you've never heard German, because this piece is in English. Though it's not sung so well (Renee is not my favorite singer... vibrato is too heavy and she tends to scoop practically every other line but...), it IS indeed, in English. "Hear ye, Israel! Hear what the Lord speaketh"... Sure seems like English to me.
-
Great music and great singing. I first heard this aria half a century ago.
A fine recording by Lois Marshall.
According to various web sites, Mendelssohn had Jenny Lind in mind
when he wrote the oratorio.
Tnx 4 the wonderful post.
-
I must admit this is not my favorite performance of this aria. Too"muddied" by heavy vibrato-can't quite understand the words. Listen to the video of Marita Solberg-clear as a bell! This aria tells the story of the second part of Elijah-very important to the story. Elijah is almost always performed in english. Oh, except my german friend told me they did it in german at home-what a surprise...
-
I have to admit this is not my favorite performance of this aria. Her heavy vibrato "muddies" some of the words. She is responsible for telling the story to begin the second half of Elijah. This oratorio is almost always performed in English, although my German friend sang it in german at home-no surprise there!
This is really terrible. No diction. No technique. Keep her!
cleanears 1 year ago
@cleanears och :/
PukKoleszka 1 year ago