Top Comments
All Comments (54)
-
awsome, this song is amazing,,,,, i love it
-
@atgskater14 perhaps what you guys are mixing up is... NOT Baba... but rather, in WGFAgain, the solo at the end was redone. And that is it. Not the entire song or anything... JUST the solo at the end. If you watch the different camera angles, you'll see that they aren't all the same compared to the 'movie' edited version. Either way, this is him doing the real drums here, and for 99% of the WGFA video as well.
-
I never said a session man covered for keith but thanks for the message,
-
@kaye789 This Myth is Busted - there was no session man. For more information on this, check out Chapter 38 of "Dear Boy: The Life of Keith Moon" (by Tony Fletcher, 2010). Or to read an excerpt regarding drum overdubs, just open the Video Description in the above video. I hope this puts this rumor to rest.
-
@atgskater14 I found this video, thanks. The narrator says: "The sound on this film is not Keith's live performance. It is a recording made later in the studio". There is no mention of a session man. I researched this further and found a very interesting passage from Chapter 38 of "Dear Boy: The Life of Keith Moon" (by Tony Fletcher, 2010). I have posted this excerpt to the Video Description so click above to read it! So, as they say - this Myth is Busted.
-
Ok for some reason it is not letting me put the link address in this comment however the video that varafies my claim can be found if you type in "Keith Moon Bio" into the search bar and then click on Keith Moon Bio 6, and it is not roger who says this it is the narrator
-
@atgskater14 Hey man, that would be awesome & thanks. If you found the video I would gladly stand corrected! I appreciate new information and hey, I wasn't there in '78 so I really can't know for sure. Hope to hear from ya & take care. :)
-
I know I have found a video where roger in an interview admits that the drumming on "The Kids Are Alright" movie is studio I'll try to find it for you.
-
That being said I DO remember some talk of John re-doing some of his own basslines for the film remaster. But just getting some sessionist to replace John's or Keith's parts - it's sacrilege!
-
@atgskater14 I dunno man - let's find a link that verifies your claim. As @ChroniclesOfSpring and others mention (I think rightly), what we *hear* is exactly what we *see* Keith do in the video - for instance at 03:10. Would not a sessionist play over the mistake, while the video editor cuts away from the drums to complete the illusion? As a musician, an editor, and as someone who has seen the movie multiple times - I see no evidence to support the "sessionist" theory re: Keith. Sorry!



i really love keith moon
margieox 4 years ago 9
moonie was fucked... at 3:10 he thinks that's the stop... then hits the snare after the actual stop. it's terrible compared to '71 moonie. no one will ever touch moonie in his prime.
ChroniclesOfSpring 1 year ago 4