Background of Korean martial arts
Uploader Comments (BuffonMusa)
Top Comments
-
Did you watch all of my videos? What you said have been refuted. I've read Kim Yushin on Samguk Sagi Retsuden, there was nothing about sword art. I've read Bonguk Geom on MTD, it just introduced a folk tale and the author labeled the 7 years old boy as the origin of the sword art but he also wrote it's newly made one. As I said there were points of a Korean learned sword art but it had never been nation wide culture and nobody inherited it.
All Comments (423)
-
Childish japanese ...sad and pathetic
-
lol thats what i said; they once had all their own stuff, but it got taken away. So people should give them a break.
-
@buakawfan333 It is possible for Korea not to have any sword arts... Sword art were wiped out after the Three Kingdoms Period, because of confucianism thinking that placed academic study over the value of martial arts. Koreans had sword arts, however they are completely wiped out now.
-
@BuffonMusa To be fair the WTF organization of Taekwondo makes up a completely fabricated history to their martial art. However the ITF the original Taekwondo organization completely accepts its history of being created from Shotokan Karate and it is evident as the moves are almost exactly the same, So i suppose not ALL Korean martial arts fabricate, well at least not the ITF however it is become a trend in Korean martial arts to fabricate.
-
North China Herald 5 May 1905
Esson Third
No land could possibly make a greater showing for bribery and corruption than Korea herself.
On no piece of ground have men deceived and been deceived more universally than in this peninsula.
No Government ever existed that was more infected with rottenness to the bones, cheating, lying, defrauding.
But Korea has grown accustomed to and unconscious of her own way of doing such things and sees only the fault of others.
-
So what?! Just because it isnt mention in any books! This says nothing but it is not written down. Again you can look here at yout. on Teakkyun, Subyokchigi, Sunmudo, Gicheon. Did you? They are very unique. Even the modern MA Hapkido is developed separately from Aikido and its quite different from its roots Daito ryu.
-
And it is the almost only MA book in Korean history, still translation of Chinese MA book. Therefore Korea didn't develop own MA according to professor Uozumi.
@BuffonSarutobi
continued...
So the source from wikipedia is still possible and valid. Kendo merged and supplanted traditional Korean sword...
You did mention about Samguk Sagi, did you come across Kim Yushin story?
Take a look at this .thehistoryblog.cm/archives/2583 So it's possible that during silla period there's sword art. There's record of silla(新罗) sword art in 武藝圖譜通志.
halfbottleofwater 2 months ago
@halfbottleofwater
So what you see as Korean martial arts today are basically all copies because Koreans didn't have martial art culture except archery. Try to find photos of Korean martial arts during Joseon period, there's none.
BuffonMusa 2 months ago 2
@BuffonMusa In the choson period didn't exist photo, are you ignorant?
do you live in the real world? hahaha
uritan2012 1 month ago
@uritan2012
Photos of late Joseon period are existing. What are you trying to say?
BuffonMusa 1 month ago
@halfbottleofwater
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
watch?v=N0NObemdQDE
watch?v=uxe-qMPbxQ4
watch?v=SW4J5WCrCEU
watch?v=J5ST2g-V0YU
watch?v=vApfSD3g0C0
BuffonMusa 2 months ago
@halfbottleofwater
Here's Korea's infamous Uriginal method. They copy, add something to make difference, created far-fetched history, claim those are Korean original.
Korea chose Taekwondo which was copy of Karate for Korean official olympic game.If they had "truly traditional" one, they didn't have to pick the copy one.
BuffonMusa 2 months ago 10