Alone - Allison Iraheta, Carrie Underwood, Ramiele Malubay

Three generations of Americal Idol Contestants (Allison Iraheta, Carrie Underwood, Ramiele Malubay), singing the same song...

ALone By Heart

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Alone
• Allison
• Iraheta
• Carrie
• Underwood
• Ramiele
• Malubay
• Heart
• American
• Idol

[rebapearce95]

ive been waiting for one of these..nice work. but i love allison's version better

[chesthair22]

thanks man..

[extranosito]

I love Carry Underwood but Allison's version is better that the rest. Allison is just amazing

[kmskms8]

umm okay thats ur opion but i really think it sounds way better and more natural with allison she is just more of my cup of tea she has that really griddy rock voice which i love so i guess u dont but i think allison can hit sme highnotes maybe not that high but she has a rocker voice not country so clearly allisons is better

[malemuk246]

Alone by Heart is the best anyways.

these girls are doing fine but still just covers

[j0921]

RAmiele is still have the best version like her heart felt version of it.. its too addicting though the live isnt good enough.. but still she have the best version of it.. Go Ramiele..

[Melinaforever9]

allison's voice can also cross into other genres besides rock too. and there isn't a law saying that alone cant be sung low...

[CFNumeroUno]

Yes, they do have different voices. Carrie is a soprano...Allison is either an alto or a mezzo. Hence Carrie's natural aptitude with belting and sustaining much higher notes. Allison's strength is her lower register. That's where her greatest power and best intonation is. Carrie's is in her upper register.

and yes, Carrie sings country, but her voice can cross into other genres as well. Check out her live performances of "Paradise City" by Guns N Roses.

[Melinaforever9]

thats because they have different kinds of voices! carrie has a country voice and allison is 1000% rocker!

[CFNumeroUno]

I never said that Allison is bad; I merely said that her attempts at higher notes are marred by the strained quality of her vocals when she gets up there. It's not an OPINION that Carrie is a soprano with a far greater upper range than Allison....it's a stone-cold FACT. It's not an OPINION that Allison's upper register sounds extremely thin and brittle...it's a stone-cold FACT. It's not an OPINION that Carrie was singing higher notes and with far greater ease at age 16...it's a stone-cold FACT.

[CFNumeroUno]

again, WHY are the allison fans giving me thumbs downs for stating the FACTS?? carrie has a MUCH higher range than allison (you don't even have to be a vocal expert to know this) and a far greater NATURAL knack for power-belting. Allison's delivery is EXTREMELY strained, she doesn't have the type of voice that can withstand loud, high singing for extended periods of time. That's why even her talking voice gets hoarse after a while, and she sounds like she's going to cough up one of her lungs!

[CFNumeroUno]

LMFAO. try again. Carrie had a higher range than Allison even when she was 16. She hit a high F# in full chest voice like it You can spew as much BS as you want to, but I actually have an education in vocal anatomy, so you WILL NOT BE SUCCESSFUL in an argument with me. Carrie is a soprano, whereas Allison is an alto. There is NO comparison where range is concerned. Carrie smokes her.

[Melinaforever9]

allison is only 17! even carrie underwood would kill for a range like allison's when she was 17

[MrJSpicoli]

I don't know anything about music, but Allison's version is the only one that brings tears. Is that evidence enough?