Top Comments
All Comments (15)
-
@potsos wow, someone on youtube putting up a balanced and well thought argument, thank you, you are one in a million!
-
@k9genesis Disagree about Binaural and Yield, but I welcome your opinion. I don't know Dave A. and I'm guessing you don't either. He sure doesn't seem like a douche to me. But if he is, I couldn't care less because I'm a making a judgment on his musical ability, not his personality.
-
@potsos i personally think that yield and Binaural were creatively their most diverse work.. and dissing Dave A is a valid thing to do, the guy is a douche..
-
@potsos Yeah, a really bad cover! I know that's mean but it does sound slow and sloppy. I couldn't listen to all of it! I had to listen to the Singles version just to get this one out of my head! Didn't want it in there!!! :)
-
@afireuncontained31 Yeah, listening to it again and this version sounds like a bad cover. There's no accounting for taste, but I just don't see how anyone could prefer this slow, sloppy version.
-
@potsos I agree with you 100%!!!!! I like the other one better!!!
-
Its Jeff Ament!



I love Dave Krusen but I must respectively disagree. I know from interviews that Dave Ament and the rest of the band have said they prefer this version and say it's got the true essence of the song as they intended it, but it's just not as cathartic or pleasing to me as the Singles version. The band's penchant for dissing everything Dave A. did is tiresome. He was easily the best drummer the band ever had (in my humble opinion) with Vs and Vitalogy being the bands creative high point.
potsos 1 year ago 3
@SR20DET91 Your nuts! Singles version way better.
mazter17 1 year ago 2