General Lee and Stuart

General Robert E. Lee and General J.E.B. Stuart in the movie Gettysburg

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• General
• Robert
• E.
• Lee
• J.E.B.
• Stuart
• Gettysburg

[RebelSoldat1]

@RebelSoldat1 Go study history. I can send you a personal message explaining how each event rests upon another.

[RebelSoldat1]

@RebelSoldat1 Cont> and no, I will not delete the comments. So don't be scared

[BGThomasHillhouse]

@rebel2276 "Eric J. Wittenburg" wrote the book. It is rather confusing, but I know your research is sound. I will send you on a email on other books I read in the hospital and flags mention, etc. Be safe out there!

[BGThomasHillhouse]

@rebel2276 I highly doubt this will be over, I remember very well what your father went through and it scares me that I will be going through it. In the event, that I can not work on the flags, I will turn it all over to you. See that justice is done.

[BGThomasHillhouse]

@rebel2276 For my records, do you know of any New York Cavalry Regiments that captured Confederate Flags? Also, if you have any information on New York Cavalry Regiments that lost Flags? "Anything New York" at the Battle of Brandy Station, thank you for any help!

[Shafeone]

@rebel2276 You're right Reb. Such an obscure topic like the Civil War is only the domain of the small schrivners like yourself. First of all I know who won which already puts me head and shoulders above a cataloguer of minutia. Actually why am I doing this? I am in discussion with a man who believes that Lee WON the PA campaign. LOL. Enough said.

[Shafeone]

@rebel2276 Reb, if you would like to get into an indepth discussion about the politics, the economiics and the Constitutional issues behind slavery and the first 75 years of the Republic I wil happily oblige. You will find however that steering the conversation back to the number of stiches in the Louisiana Tigers battle flag and then offering that you are the only American to have set foot in our country's largets library will not help you much. So, shall we discuss slavery?

[Shafeone]

@rebel2276 Is your definition of "Union biased" one who believes that the North won the Civil War? When it comes to bias, I would think a man whose handle is "Rebel" would be quite expert at that subject no doubt. By the way, Grant won, Lee lost. Get over it.

[Shafeone]

@rebel2276 LOL. You mean such brick shitting as "ok what would you like to discuss"? And as for off-topic, hmm let's see somehow you felt it necessary to bring up Toombs' 400 Georgians in a discussion of Lee at Antietam. You offer up pathetic and pedantic factoids as if they are even remotely relevant to the main story of these battles and campaigns. As I said, if you want to know how many bullet holes are in a regiment's flag you're the guy. As to who won the Civil War? well...

[Shafeone]

@rebel2276 Do you even know what "hypocrite" means? How am I a "hypocrite"? (And how do you have so much time to blog from "Afghanistan" anyway?)