Char Refutes Determinism
Loading...
Uploader Comments (dawgie102)
All Comments (11)
-
Lol expresses laughter. This is funny because you take it so seriously but your really not making any sense.
-
Amen
-
I disagree. While thought is immaterial, this does not mean it is not a part of our natural world. Because of this some would like to assign it to the realm of the super natural. A vacuum is immaterial by definition, that is not to say it is not part of our natural world and subject to it. The same applies to our thoughts. To assume that our thoughts are a product of just thinking is ascribing the event as a supernatural one.
-
It is an argument exposing said person as a self contradictor. He is a good example of many determinists in his class.
-
alot of moderns don't know the limits of physical science nor the object of such..
The object of the physical sciences is the individual, material, concrete,(including protons etc.) and their relation to each other. No THOUGHT.. THe lower cannot give rise to the higher, nor can non- thinking neurons give rise to thought and consciousness.
-
Also, when I use wording like rational thought, changing mind, think.. I know you would like to twist these words to show what you believe is hypocrisy. In reality, these are nothing more than competing chemical reactions in the brain. Consequence for an action may cause you to 'change your mind' or a different set of neurons to fire. This is all I am referring to.
-
Your last argument for free will which was a personal anecdote regarding a person writing a deterministic piece in a newspaper called free will. While mildly amusing, this is not an argument.
-
Further, you can rationalize the punishment of criminals as a precautionary measure so that a would be criminal takes punishment for his actions into account. The sub conscience mind could decide not to commit a crime based on the consequences of that crime. Just as the mind would weigh the costs and benefits for getting off the couch to make a sandwich. Punishing criminals 1. sets a moral framework for a society 2. acts as a deterrent
5:49
Henry Mooreby sheilagraber10,071 views- 1:56
Margie Refutes Determinismby dawgie102191 views
- 10:53
Rosetta - A Determinism Of Moralityby TheIndestructableD13,157 views
- 10:06
Dennett on free will and determinismby silverstream31470,107 views
- 2:28
Downhill FreeRide in Wood Parkby adsaru6,293 views
- 1:41
Two Rex catsby dawgie10236 views
- 23:37
Can Free Will Emerge from Determinism in Quantum Theory?by infophilosopher524 views
- 9:23
Determinism: The Inescapable Conclusion /by Nykytyne2 (mirrored)by unseenstrings668 views
- 12:02
Determinism - God's Flawby Dom0nePhilosophy8,071 views
- 3:03
Dennett on Determinismby LennyBound16,384 views
- 1:41:12
Daniel Dennett - Free Will Determinism and Evolutionby venompangx12,849 views
- 19:35
mikemack28 on Determinismby jeffsmithluedke4,156 views
- 9:37
Free Will, Determinism, and Compatibilismby XOmniverse7,140 views
- 2:14
Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow (1963)by evsc16,755 views
- 2:11
Free Will vs. Determinismby OrionsChild12,984 views
- 5:50
One aspect of Quantum Theory: inherent non-determinismby PhysicsMathCharlatan419 views
- 7:57
Free will and determinism (2/10)by OUlearn18,371 views
- 9:57
Rosetta - A Determinism Of Moralityby unARTigNYC28,357 views
- 18:49
7.1 Free Will, Determinism and Choiceby oxford2,432 views
- 15:00
Free will, determinism and fate: Arthur M. Youngby ArthurMYoung1,025 views
Lol, none of that debuts anything. lol
MSlapik 4 years ago
If you have no free will, whatever you say or think is meaningless. LOL does not refute anything. I don't understand why people who are determinists discuss anything w/anyone.
dawgie102 4 years ago