Evidence for Evolution: 2 - "junk DNA"
Loading...
3,705
Loading...
Uploader Comments (smaakjeks)
see all
All Comments (237)
-
I've said all I wanted to express in the comments. Go to the "all comments" page and search for your own username to see the discussion.
-
So then I take it you admit this video is false. Or have you not kept up with the current data?
-
We had this discussion a year ago. Look in the comments....
Loading...
The point is pseudogenes have been found to have function, so your video is false. You continue to persist that if something has not been figured out yet, then therefore it has no function, even though we're constantly discovering more function everyday.
Pseudogenes have been defined as nonfunctional sequences of genomic DNA originally derived from functional genes, but we now know they have important function. So of course their definition has to reformulated. Thats just circular thinking.
benthemiester 3 weeks ago
@benthemiester
No, the point is that junk-DNA is vestigial sequences from polyploidy.
smaakjeks 3 weeks ago
Are you saying that this so called junk DNA including pseudogenes which are in fact known to perform these important regulatory functions is irrelevant? Or that it does not contradict your video when it clearly does? Why have you ignored the literature?
benthemiester 3 weeks ago
@benthemiester
Some pseudogenes have been found to have function, and there is a discussion about whether or not these should then be called pseudogenes. The question is: are there gene sequences with no known function? The answer is yes. Though, as I explained last year, the point isn't that these sequences are completely non-functional, but that they are clear evidence of polyploidy. You can compare junk-DNA with vestigial organs. Non-functionality isn't the point.
smaakjeks 3 weeks ago
Ill take that as a no and that you have not kept up with the current data.
benthemiester 3 weeks ago
@benthemiester
You have not expressed anything new since the discussion we had. Bring up a new point and I will address it.
smaakjeks 3 weeks ago